FT·SCI·020Logic & Epistemology

Monastic Debate

རྩོད་པ

Wyliertsod paSanskritVādaDatefrom the 12th century

Monastic debate is the formal, physically animated method of argument through which Tibetan monks and nuns test their understanding of philosophy.

Also known asTsopa · rTsod pa · Tibetan debate · Dialectical debate · Tsennyi

རྩོད་པ

Debate is the characteristic teaching method of Tibetan scholastic education. For several hours a day, students gather in the monastery courtyard to argue points of doctrine in pairs or groups under set rules. The aim is to examine a position until its weaknesses are exposed and its meaning understood, and to train memory, quick reasoning and confidence. The practice is most developed in the Gelug school and is also used in Sakya, Kagyu, Nyingma and Bon colleges.

One party, the defender, sits and maintains a thesis. The other, the challenger, stands and poses questions that draw out consequences of the defender’s answers. The challenger marks each point with a loud clap of the right hand on the left and a stamp of the foot, gestures given symbolic meanings such as closing the door to unfortunate rebirth. The defender may reply only in a few set ways: accepting, asking for a reason, denying that the reason is established, or denying that the consequence follows.

The form grew out of the Indian rules of disputation and took shape at Sangphu monastery in the twelfth century. Advancement through the curriculum depends on performance in debate, and the examinations for the geshe degree are public debates before the assembled monastery. Nuns now follow the same training: the first twenty women to earn the Geshema degree received it from the Dalai Lama in December 2016. Debate has also shaped how Tibetan scholars engage scientists in dialogue.

Connections

12 linked records across the archive.

Sources

References consulted for this record.

  1. 01Alexander Berzin, The Gelug Monastic Education System — Study Buddhism
  2. 02Ceremony to Award Nuns the First Geshe-ma Degrees — Office of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, 2016
  3. 03Georges Dreyfus, The Sound of Two Hands Clapping: The Education of a Tibetan Buddhist Monk (University of California Press, 2003)
  4. 04Daniel Perdue, Debate in Tibetan Buddhism (Snow Lion, 1992)