{"wing":"Science & Cosmos","count":40,"records":[{"id":"tibetan-calendar","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-calendar/","code":"FT·SCI·001","name":"Tibetan Calendar","aliases":["Phugpa calendar","Phukpa calendar","Tibetan lunisolar calendar","Bod kyi lo tho","Tibetan lunar calendar"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"Phugpa system from 1447","summary":"The Tibetan calendar is a lunisolar system derived from the Kalachakra Tantra, with twelve or thirteen lunar months a year and dates tied to the phases of the moon.","body":["The Tibetan calendar orders religious and civil life across the Tibetan cultural world. It is lunisolar: months follow the moon, and an extra month is added every two to three years so that the year keeps pace with the sun and the seasons. Festivals, monastic observances, medical and agricultural timings and the new year, Losar, are all fixed by it. Its mathematics comes chiefly from the Indian Kalachakra Tantra, combined with Chinese-derived names for the years.","Each month runs from new moon to new moon, with the full moon on the fifteenth. A month has thirty lunar days, each slightly shorter than a solar day, and a calendar date is assigned according to the lunar day in force at dawn. As a result some dates are skipped and others occur twice. Years are counted in sixty-year cycles beginning in 1027 and also in a royal era starting in 127 BCE, in which 2026 is the year 2153.","Two computational traditions are in use. The Phugpa system, set out by Phugpa Lhundrub Gyatso in a treatise of 1447, is followed by the Gelug, Sakya and Nyingma schools and by Men-Tsee-Khang. The Tsurphu system, based on the work of the Third Karmapa Rangjung Dorje, is used in the Karma Kagyu school. Bhutan and Mongolia keep related variants. The astronomy of the calendar has been analysed in detail by Dieter Schuh, Edward Henning and Svante Janson."],"facts":[{"label":"Origin","value":"Kalachakra Tantra astronomy with Chinese-derived year names"},{"label":"Method","value":"Lunisolar: 12 lunar months, with a 13th added every 2 to 3 years"},{"label":"Period","value":"Kalachakra system introduced in the 11th century"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Phugpa Lhundrub Gyatso; Third Karmapa Rangjung Dorje"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Oral Teachings of Pundarika (Pekar Zhalung), 1447"},{"label":"Year count","value":"Sixty-year cycles from 1027; royal era from 127 BCE"},{"label":"Example","value":"2026 CE: royal year 2153, male Fire Horse"}],"related":["science/losar","science/sixty-year-cycle","science/kartsi","science/tibetan-almanac","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/lunar-mansions","science/tibetan-astrology","masters/rangjung-dorje","deities/kalachakra","symbols/sipaho","science/eclipse-calculation","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","science/kalachakra-cosmology","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus","masters/nyatri-tsenpo","history/origin-myths-and-nyatri-tsenpo","history/kalachakra-and-first-rabjung-cycle","concepts/chotrul-duchen","concepts/saga-dawa","concepts/chokhor-duchen","concepts/shoton","concepts/lhabab-duchen","concepts/ganden-ngamcho"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""},{"title":"Dieter Schuh, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der tibetischen Kalenderrechnung (Franz Steiner Verlag, 1973)","url":""}]},{"id":"losar","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/losar/","code":"FT·SCI·002","name":"Losar","aliases":["Tibetan New Year","Lo gsar","Gyalpo Losar","Losar festival"],"tibetan":"ལོ་གསར","wylie":"lo gsar","sanskrit":"","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"","summary":"Losar is the Tibetan New Year, falling on the first day of the first lunar month in February or March and celebrated for up to fifteen days.","body":["Losar, literally ‘new year’, is the principal festival of the Tibetan calendar. It falls on the first day of the first lunisolar month, which lands in February or March, and is celebrated for fifteen days, with the first three the most important. The date is fixed by astronomical calculation and is often, though not always, the same as or close to the Chinese and Mongolian new years, since all three calendars share a common ancestry.","Preparations begin in the last days of the old year. Houses are cleaned and debts settled. On the twenty-ninth day of the twelfth month families eat guthuk, a soup with dumplings containing tokens that tease each person about the year ahead, and monasteries perform rites to cast out the old year’s misfortunes. On new year’s morning offerings are set out, including fried pastries called khapse and a decorated box of roasted barley flour and grain, and families visit temples and one another.","Tibetan tradition traces the festival to pre-Buddhist times, and it later acquired Buddhist layers, including the Great Prayer Festival founded in Lhasa by Tsongkhapa in 1409, which follows the new year. Regional new years are kept at other times, such as that of Kongpo in the tenth month. Losar is celebrated in Tibet, Bhutan, Ladakh, Sikkim, Nepal and Tibetan communities worldwide. In 2026 it fell on 18 February, opening the male Fire Horse year."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Losar"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"New year"},{"label":"Date","value":"First day of the first lunisolar month (February or March)"},{"label":"Period","value":"Fifteen days; first three days are the main celebration"},{"label":"Customs","value":"Guthuk soup on the 29th; khapse pastries; offerings; temple visits"},{"label":"Recent date","value":"18 February 2026, male Fire Horse year, royal year 2153"},{"label":"Observed in","value":"Tibet, Bhutan, Ladakh, Sikkim, Nepal and the Tibetan diaspora"}],"related":["science/tibetan-calendar","science/sixty-year-cycle","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","science/tibetan-almanac","masters/tsongkhapa","places/lhasa","symbols/cham-dance","symbols/prayer-flags","symbols/butter-lamp","symbols/torma","symbols/khata","symbols/incense-and-sang","symbols/yungdrung","symbols/sipaho","symbols/butter-sculpture","masters/nyatri-tsenpo","history/origin-myths-and-nyatri-tsenpo","concepts/monlam-chenmo","concepts/chotrul-duchen"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Losar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Losar"},{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Philippe Cornu, Tibetan Astrology (Shambhala, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"sixty-year-cycle","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/sixty-year-cycle/","code":"FT·SCI·003","name":"Sixty-Year Cycle","aliases":["Rabjung","Rab byung","Rabjyung","Sexagenary cycle","Tibetan sixty-year cycle"],"tibetan":"རབ་བྱུང","wylie":"rab byung","sanskrit":"Prabhava","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"from 1027","summary":"The rabjung is the sixty-year cycle by which Tibetans count years; the first cycle began in 1027, and the seventeenth runs from 1987 to 2046.","body":["Tibetan chronology counts years in cycles of sixty, called rabjung. A date is given by the number of the cycle and the place of the year within it, or by the year’s name. The first cycle began in 1027, the year in which, by tradition, the Kalachakra Tantra was translated into Tibetan. Because this starting point is fixed and well documented, the rabjung system allows Tibetan historical dates to be converted reliably to the Western calendar.","The cycle takes its name from the first of sixty year-names used in India, prabhava, which Tibetan renders as rabjung. In everyday use each year is instead named by pairing one of five elements with one of twelve animals, a scheme shared with China, where the cycle begins three years earlier. The first year of each Tibetan cycle is therefore a female Fire Hare year. The seventeenth cycle began in 1987; 2026 is its fortieth year, a male Fire Horse year.","Historians must take care with element-animal dates given without a cycle number, since the same name recurs every sixty years, and many errors in older scholarship arose this way. The eighteenth cycle will begin in 2047. Alongside the rabjung count, Tibetans use the royal era that starts in 127 BCE, by which 2026 is the year 2153. The cycle also underlies astrological reckoning of a person’s age, obstacle years and compatibility."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Rabjung"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian sixty-year cycle, adopted with the Kalachakra Tantra"},{"label":"Founded","value":"First cycle began in 1027 (female Fire Hare year)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Years named by 5 elements and 12 animals, or by cycle and year number"},{"label":"Current cycle","value":"17th rabjung, 1987–2046"},{"label":"Next cycle","value":"18th rabjung begins in 2047"},{"label":"Example","value":"2026: 40th year of the 17th rabjung"}],"related":["science/tibetan-calendar","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/losar","science/kartsi","science/naktsi","science/tibetan-almanac","science/mewa-and-parkha"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Losar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Losar"},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"tibetan-almanac","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-almanac/","code":"FT·SCI·004","name":"Tibetan Almanac","aliases":["Lotho","Lo tho","Tibetan astrological almanac","Datho","Men-Tsee-Khang almanac"],"tibetan":"ལོ་ཐོ","wylie":"lo tho","sanskrit":"","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"","summary":"The lotho is the yearly Tibetan almanac, which lists each day’s calendar data, festivals, eclipses and the days judged favourable for particular activities.","body":["The lotho is the printed almanac that turns the mathematics of the Tibetan calendar into a book for daily use. A new edition is calculated and issued each year. It tells the reader the date in the Tibetan and Western calendars, which dates are skipped or doubled, when the new and full moons fall, and which days carry religious significance. Households, monasteries, farmers and herders consult it throughout the year.","For each day the almanac gives five items taken from the Indian-derived system: the day of the week, the lunar day, the lunar mansion in which the moon stands, and two further factors computed from the positions of sun and moon. To these it adds the Chinese-derived data of animal, element, trigram and number for the day. It lists predicted eclipses, the dates of festivals, and guidance on days held to be suitable or unsuitable for undertakings such as travel, building or raising prayer flags.","The almanac was a principal product of the Lhasa Mentsikhang from its founding in 1916, and both the Lhasa institute and Men-Tsee-Khang in Dharamsala publish annual editions today; other traditions, including the Tsurphu school, issue their own. Calculations once made by hand on sand boards are now done largely by computer and checked by trained astrologers. Pocket and digital versions are widely used in the Tibetan diaspora."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Lotho"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Year record; almanac"},{"label":"Method","value":"Annual calculation by the Phugpa or Tsurphu system"},{"label":"Daily data","value":"Weekday, lunar day, lunar mansion and two combined factors"},{"label":"Also lists","value":"Skipped and doubled dates, eclipses, festivals, favourable days"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Men-Tsee-Khang, Dharamsala; Mentsikhang, Lhasa"}],"related":["science/tibetan-calendar","medicine/men-tsee-khang","science/kartsi","science/naktsi","science/lunar-mansions","science/eclipse-calculation","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus","science/losar","medicine/khyenrab-norbu","science/sixty-year-cycle"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"kartsi","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/kartsi/","code":"FT·SCI·005","name":"Kartsi","aliases":["Kar tsi","dKar rtsis","sKar rtsis","White calculation","White astrology","Indian astro-science"],"tibetan":"དཀར་རྩིས","wylie":"dkar rtsis","sanskrit":"Jyotiṣa","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"from the 11th century","summary":"Kartsi, or ‘white calculation’, is the Indian-derived branch of Tibetan astro-science that computes the motions of sun, moon and planets for the calendar.","body":["Kartsi is the mathematical astronomy of the Tibetan tradition. The name is usually explained as ‘white calculation’, after the Tibetan word for India, Gyakar, in contrast to the ‘black calculation’ that came from China. A variant spelling means ‘star calculation’. Kartsi supplies the calendar, the positions of the heavenly bodies and the prediction of eclipses, and it is the part of Tibetan astro-science closest to astronomy in the modern sense.","Its source is the first chapter of the Kalachakra Tantra and the commentary Stainless Light, which reached Tibet in the eleventh century. From given constants and a starting date, the astrologer computes the mean and true positions of the sun and moon, the five visible planets and the lunar nodes. Two levels of method are distinguished: a fuller system held to be definitive and a shortened one for routine work. The results yield the five daily components of the almanac.","Tibetan scholars refined the inherited constants over centuries. Buton Rinchen Drub and the Third Karmapa wrote on the subject in the fourteenth century, Phugpa Lhundrub Gyatso established the dominant school in 1447, and Desi Sangye Gyatso surveyed the field in his White Beryl in the 1680s. Modern analysis shows the system to be a competent pre-telescopic model whose errors accumulate slowly. It is taught at Men-Tsee-Khang and in monastic colleges with a Kalachakra curriculum."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Kartsi"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"White calculation (from Gyakar, India); also 'star calculation'"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian astronomy transmitted in the Kalachakra Tantra"},{"label":"Period","value":"In Tibet from the 11th century"},{"label":"Method","value":"Arithmetic computation of sun, moon, five planets and lunar nodes"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Kalachakra Tantra, chapter 1; Stainless Light commentary"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Buton, Rangjung Dorje, Phugpa Lhundrub Gyatso, Desi Sangye Gyatso"}],"related":["science/naktsi","science/tibetan-calendar","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/eclipse-calculation","science/lunar-mansions","science/tibetan-almanac","science/kalachakra-cosmology","masters/buton-rinchen-drub","science/sixty-year-cycle","science/tibetan-astrology","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"lunar-mansions","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/lunar-mansions/","code":"FT·SCI·006","name":"Lunar Mansions","aliases":["Gyukar","rGyu skar","Nakshatra","Twenty-seven constellations","Moon constellations"],"tibetan":"རྒྱུ་སྐར","wylie":"rgyu skar","sanskrit":"Nakṣatra","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"","summary":"The lunar mansions are the twenty-seven star groups along the moon’s path that Tibetan astronomy uses to mark the moon’s position and to name the months.","body":["The lunar mansions divide the band of sky through which the moon travels into equal segments, each named after a star or star group. The moon passes through roughly one mansion each day and returns to its starting point in a little over twenty-seven days. Tibetan astronomy took the system from India, where the mansions are called nakshatra. The Tibetan term, gyukar, means ‘moving stars’, that is, the stars against which the moon and planets move.","The Indian-derived branch of Tibetan calculation counts twenty-seven mansions, each spanning thirteen degrees and twenty minutes of the circle; a twenty-eighth is sometimes inserted, and the Chinese-derived branch uses a set of twenty-eight. The series begins with the mansion called Takar. The mansion occupied by the moon is one of the five items given for each day in the almanac, and the positions of the sun and planets are also expressed in mansions.","The mansions give the Tibetan months their formal names, each month being called after the mansion in which its full moon falls. The fourth month, Saga Dawa, in which the Buddha’s birth, awakening and passing are commemorated, takes its name from the mansion Saga. A person’s birth mansion is noted in horoscopes, and combinations of mansion and weekday are classed as favourable or unfavourable for beginning activities."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Gyukar"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Moving stars; lunar constellations"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian nakshatra system"},{"label":"Number","value":"27 (28 in some reckonings and in the Chinese-derived system)"},{"label":"Span","value":"13 degrees 20 minutes each"},{"label":"Method","value":"Marks the daily position of the moon; names the twelve months"},{"label":"Example","value":"Saga Dawa, the fourth month, named after the mansion Saga"}],"related":["science/kartsi","science/tibetan-calendar","science/tibetan-almanac","science/eclipse-calculation","science/tibetan-astrology","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/kalachakra-cosmology"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Nakshatra — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakshatra"},{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"}]},{"id":"eclipse-calculation","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/eclipse-calculation/","code":"FT·SCI·007","name":"Eclipse Calculation","aliases":["Za dzin","gZa' 'dzin","Tibetan eclipse prediction","Rahu calculation","Solar and lunar eclipses"],"tibetan":"གཟའ་འཛིན","wylie":"gza' 'dzin","sanskrit":"Grahaṇa","category":"Calendar & Astronomy","era":"from the 11th century","summary":"Tibetan astronomers predict solar and lunar eclipses arithmetically from the Kalachakra system, treating the moon’s nodes as the invisible planet Rahu.","body":["The prediction of eclipses is the most demanding task of traditional Tibetan astronomy and the main test of its accuracy. The Tibetan word for an eclipse means ‘seizure by a planet’. The planet in question is Rahu, which in Indian and Tibetan astronomy stands for the points where the moon’s path crosses the sun’s. An eclipse can occur only when a new or full moon falls near one of these points, and the calculation determines when that happens.","The method comes from the Kalachakra Tantra. The astrologer computes the true positions of sun and moon and the position of Rahu, which moves slowly backward through the sky, completing a circuit in about eighteen and a half years. If the moon at full or new is close enough to Rahu’s head or tail, an eclipse is forecast, with its expected time, extent and duration. Forecasts are published in the yearly almanac.","Because the inherited constants are approximations, traditional predictions can err by hours, and some forecast eclipses are not visible from Tibet. Tibetan scholars were aware of the problem. From the eighteenth century, astronomers in Amdo and at the Qing court adopted Chinese methods that incorporated European astronomy, and these were used specifically for eclipses. Eclipse days are religiously significant: the effects of actions are said to be multiplied, and many people devote them to prayer."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Za dzin; nyi dzin (solar), da dzin (lunar)"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Seizure by a planet"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Kalachakra Tantra; later Chinese methods from the 18th century"},{"label":"Method","value":"Arithmetic positions of sun, moon and the lunar nodes (Rahu)"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Kalachakra Tantra, chapter 1, and Tibetan manuals based on it"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Predictions broadly reliable, with timing errors of up to hours"}],"related":["science/kartsi","science/tibetan-almanac","science/tibetan-calendar","deities/rahula","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/lunar-mansions","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""},{"title":"Dieter Schuh, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der tibetischen Kalenderrechnung (Franz Steiner Verlag, 1973)","url":""}]},{"id":"twelve-animals-and-five-elements","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements/","code":"FT·SCI·008","name":"Twelve Animals and Five Elements","aliases":["Lokhor Chunyi","Twelve-year cycle","Animal years","Tibetan zodiac","Lo 'khor bcu gnyis"],"tibetan":"ལོ་འཁོར་བཅུ་གཉིས","wylie":"lo 'khor bcu gnyis","sanskrit":"","category":"Astrology & Divination","era":"","summary":"Tibetan years are named by pairing one of twelve animals with one of five elements, a scheme of Chinese origin that Tibetans use for dating, ages and horoscopes.","body":["The cycle of twelve animals is the most familiar part of Tibetan timekeeping. Every year is assigned an animal, in the order mouse, ox, tiger, hare, dragon, snake, horse, sheep, monkey, bird, dog and pig, and every Tibetan knows the animal of his or her birth year. The scheme was adopted from China, and the Tibetan list differs from the Chinese only in small points of naming. The animal year changes at Losar.","The animals are combined with five elements: wood, fire, earth, iron and water. Each element governs two successive years, the first counted as male and the second as female, so that the full sequence of element-animal pairs repeats after sixty years. Astrologers also assign to each birth year separate elements for life force, body, personal power and fortune, and judge their relations as those of mother, child, friend or enemy.","The system has practical uses. Ages are reckoned by animal years, with a person counted as one at birth and a year older at each Losar. Every twelfth year, when the birth animal returns, is treated as an obstacle year calling for caution and ritual. Compatibility between marriage partners is assessed by comparing animals and elements. These are customary practices of the Chinese-derived branch of Tibetan astrology and carry no claim to scientific prediction."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Lokhor chunyi"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Cycle of twelve years"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Chinese calendar, adopted in Tibet"},{"label":"Animals","value":"Mouse, ox, tiger, hare, dragon, snake, horse, sheep, monkey, bird, dog, pig"},{"label":"Elements","value":"Wood, fire, earth, iron, water; each rules two years"},{"label":"Full cycle","value":"60 years (5 elements x 12 animals, alternating male and female)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Used for year names, ages, obstacle years and compatibility"}],"related":["science/sixty-year-cycle","science/naktsi","science/tibetan-astrology","science/mewa-and-parkha","science/five-elements","science/losar","science/tibetan-calendar","symbols/windhorse"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Tibetan calendar — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_calendar"},{"title":"Philippe Cornu, Tibetan Astrology (Shambhala, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"naktsi","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/naktsi/","code":"FT·SCI·009","name":"Naktsi","aliases":["Nagtsi","Nag rtsis","Jungtsi","Black calculation","Elemental calculation","Chinese astro-science"],"tibetan":"ནག་རྩིས","wylie":"nag rtsis","sanskrit":"","category":"Astrology & Divination","era":"","summary":"Naktsi, or ‘black calculation’, is the Chinese-derived branch of Tibetan astrology, which reads the interplay of elements, animals, numbers and trigrams.","body":["Naktsi is the branch of Tibetan astrology concerned with the fortunes of individuals and the choice of favourable times. Its name, ‘black calculation’, comes from Gyanak, the Tibetan word for China, and carries no sense of sorcery. It is also called jungtsi, ‘elemental calculation’, because its reasoning turns on five elements. Where kartsi computes the heavens, naktsi interprets the qualities of years, months, days and hours.","The system works with five elements, wood, fire, earth, iron and water; twelve animals; nine numbered squares called mewa; and eight trigrams called parkha. These are often drawn together on the shell of a cosmic turtle, a diagram regarded as protective. Tradition credits the Chinese princess Wencheng, who married King Songtsen Gampo in the seventh century, with bringing such texts to Tibet. Desi Sangye Gyatso gave the subject its classic exposition in the White Beryl.","Five kinds of chart are drawn up from these elements: a natal horoscope, a comparison of partners before marriage, a reading for a year of obstacles, a reading in illness, and a calculation at death that guides the timing and manner of the funeral. Such consultations remain a normal part of family life in Tibetan communities. They are a traditional interpretive art whose predictions have not been tested or supported scientifically."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Naktsi; also jungtsi"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Black calculation (from Gyanak, China); elemental calculation"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Chinese calendrical and divinatory traditions"},{"label":"Method","value":"5 elements, 12 animals, 9 mewa and 8 parkha"},{"label":"Key text","value":"White Beryl (Vaidurya Karpo), Desi Sangye Gyatso, 1680s"},{"label":"Uses","value":"Natal, marriage, obstacle-year, illness and death charts"}],"related":["science/kartsi","science/mewa-and-parkha","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","science/tibetan-astrology","science/five-elements","masters/desi-sangye-gyatso","masters/songtsen-gampo","science/mo-divination","medicine/five-elements-in-medicine","science/sixty-year-cycle","science/tibetan-almanac"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"The White Beryl Manuscript — Rubin Museum of Art","url":"https://rubinmuseum.org/the-white-beryl-manuscript/"},{"title":"Gyurme Dorje, Tibetan Elemental Divination Paintings: Illuminated Manuscripts from the White Beryl of Sangs-rgyas rGya-mtsho (John Eskenazi, 2001)","url":""}]},{"id":"tibetan-astrology","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-astrology/","code":"FT·SCI·010","name":"Tibetan Astrology","aliases":["Tsi","Tsi rig","rTsis","Tibetan astro-science","Astro-science","Tibetan astronomy and astrology"],"tibetan":"རྩིས་རིག","wylie":"rtsis rig","sanskrit":"Jyotiṣa","category":"Astrology & Divination","era":"","summary":"Tibetan astrology, or the science of calculation, joins Indian astronomy and Chinese elemental reckoning into one discipline for calendars, horoscopes and timing.","body":["Tibetans call their astrology tsi, ‘calculation’, and do not separate astronomy from astrology as modern usage does. The discipline is counted among the five minor sciences of classical learning. It has two main sources: an Indian-derived mathematical astronomy called kartsi, taken from the Kalachakra Tantra, and a Chinese-derived system of elements, animals, numbers and trigrams called naktsi. A third, smaller branch from India, known as the Arising Vowels, is used for divination.","A practitioner, called a tsipa, is trained to compute the calendar and to interpret it. The work includes producing the yearly almanac, casting horoscopes at birth, comparing the charts of prospective spouses, advising in years of obstacles and illness, and determining the proper time and procedures for a funeral. Astrology is closely tied to medicine: physicians consult it for the gathering of herbs and the timing of certain treatments, and the two were taught in the same institutions.","The standard reference is the White Beryl, completed by the regent Desi Sangye Gyatso in the 1680s. Astrology has been taught at the Mentsikhang since its founding in Lhasa in 1916 and at Men-Tsee-Khang in Dharamsala since 1961. Its astronomical side yields testable calendar and eclipse data. Its predictive side is a traditional interpretive practice without scientific validation, valued by its users as guidance and as part of a shared culture."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Tsi; tsi rig"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Calculation; science of calculation"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian (Kalachakra) and Chinese sources, with Tibetan additions"},{"label":"Method","value":"Kartsi (astronomy), naktsi (elements) and Arising Vowels"},{"label":"Key text","value":"White Beryl (Vaidurya Karpo), Desi Sangye Gyatso, 1680s"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Men-Tsee-Khang, Dharamsala; Mentsikhang, Lhasa"},{"label":"Practitioner","value":"Tsipa (astrologer)"}],"related":["science/kartsi","science/naktsi","science/tibetan-calendar","science/mewa-and-parkha","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","medicine/men-tsee-khang","science/ten-sciences","masters/desi-sangye-gyatso","deities/rahula","symbols/tenfold-powerful-one","symbols/sipaho","symbols/windhorse","symbols/four-dignities","medicine/dream-and-omen-diagnosis","medicine/desi-sangye-gyatso-medicine","science/lunar-mansions","science/mo-divination","science/five-sciences","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus","places/mindrolling","history/kalachakra-and-first-rabjung-cycle","texts/kalachakra-tantra","concepts/oracle"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Philippe Cornu, Tibetan Astrology (Shambhala, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"mewa-and-parkha","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/mewa-and-parkha/","code":"FT·SCI·011","name":"Mewa and Parkha","aliases":["Mewa gu","Nine mewa","Parkha gye","Eight trigrams","Nine magic-square numbers","sMe ba and spar kha"],"tibetan":"སྨེ་བ་དང་སྤར་ཁ","wylie":"sme ba dang spar kha","sanskrit":"","category":"Astrology & Divination","era":"","summary":"The nine mewa and eight parkha are numbered squares and trigrams of Chinese origin that Tibetan astrologers use to describe years, people and directions.","body":["Mewa and parkha are two sets of symbols in the Chinese-derived branch of Tibetan astrology. The mewa, a word that also means ‘mole’ or ‘mark’, are the numbers one to nine arranged in a square in which every row, column and diagonal adds up to fifteen. The parkha are the eight trigrams, figures of three whole or broken lines, known in China as the bagua. Both are drawn on the protective chart displayed in many Tibetan homes.","Each mewa has a colour and an element: one, six and eight are white, two is black, three blue, four green, five yellow, and seven and nine red. A mewa is assigned to each year in a descending series, so that a person’s birth mewa is fixed, and the pattern of mewa and year names repeats only after 180 years. The eight parkha, named Li, Khon, Dwa, Khen, Kham, Gin, Zin and Zon, stand for fire, earth, iron, sky, water, mountain, wood and wind, and each governs a direction.","Astrologers use the birth mewa to characterise a person and to judge relations between people. A parkha is calculated for each year of life by counting around the eight trigrams, by different rules for men and women, and it indicates which directions are held to be favourable for travel, doorways or sleeping. The methods are described in Desi Sangye Gyatso’s White Beryl. They are a customary divinatory practice and have no demonstrated predictive validity."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Mewa gu (nine mewa); parkha gye (eight parkha)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Chinese magic square (Luoshu) and eight trigrams (bagua)"},{"label":"Mewa colours","value":"1 white, 2 black, 3 blue, 4 green, 5 yellow, 6 white, 7 red, 8 white, 9 red"},{"label":"Parkha","value":"Li, Khon, Dwa, Khen, Kham, Gin, Zin, Zon"},{"label":"Great cycle","value":"180 years (three sixty-year cycles)"},{"label":"Key text","value":"White Beryl, Desi Sangye Gyatso, 1680s"},{"label":"Method","value":"Birth-year number and yearly trigram used in horoscopes"}],"related":["science/naktsi","science/tibetan-astrology","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","science/sixty-year-cycle","science/five-elements","science/mo-divination","masters/desi-sangye-gyatso"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Philippe Cornu, Tibetan Astrology (Shambhala, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"mo-divination","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/mo-divination/","code":"FT·SCI·012","name":"Mo Divination","aliases":["Mo","Sho mo","Dice divination","Tibetan divination","Rosary divination","Trengmo"],"tibetan":"མོ","wylie":"mo","sanskrit":"","category":"Astrology & Divination","era":"attested from the 8th–10th centuries","summary":"Mo is the Tibetan practice of divination by dice, rosary beads or other lots, performed by lamas and lay people to guide decisions great and small.","body":["Mo is the general Tibetan term for divination by casting lots. It is distinct from astrology: no calculation from the birth date is involved, and the answer comes from a single cast made after prayer. Tibetans consult mo about journeys, business, illness, marriage and the choice of rituals, usually by asking a lama known for the skill. Manuscripts from Dunhuang and other Silk Road sites show that dice divination was practised by Tibetans between the eighth and tenth centuries.","Several methods are in use. In dice divination the diviner invokes a deity, casts the dice and looks up the result in a manual. In rosary divination a section of beads is seized at random and counted off until a remainder is left. Other techniques use dough balls containing written answers, a mirror, arrows or pebbles. A widely used manual by Mipham Rinpoche (1846–1912) employs a die marked with the six syllables of Manjushri’s mantra, thrown twice.","Buddhist teachers explain mo as working through the blessing of the deity invoked and the interdependence of events, and they caution that its results depend on the diviner’s sincerity. The dough-ball method has been used in weighty matters, including choices among candidates for religious office. Mo remains common in monasteries and households across the Tibetan world. Scholars study it as a social and religious practice; no claim to scientific validity is made for it."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Mo"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Divination by lots"},{"label":"Method","value":"Dice, rosary beads, dough balls, mirror, arrows or pebbles"},{"label":"Period","value":"Dice divination texts from Dunhuang, 8th–10th centuries"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Mipham Rinpoche's Manjushri dice manual (19th century)"},{"label":"Deities invoked","value":"Manjushri, Palden Lhamo, Tara and others"}],"related":["science/tibetan-astrology","science/naktsi","masters/mipham-rinpoche","deities/manjushri","deities/palden-lhamo","symbols/mala","texts/dunhuang-manuscripts","medicine/dream-and-omen-diagnosis","science/mewa-and-parkha"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mo (divination) — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mo_(divination)"},{"title":"2018 Khyentse Lecture: Buddhism and Divination in Tibet — UC Berkeley Group in Buddhist Studies","url":"https://buddhiststudies.berkeley.edu/news/2018-khyentse-lecture-buddhism-and-divination-tibet"},{"title":"Jamgon Mipham, Mo: Tibetan Divination System, trans. Jay Goldberg (Snow Lion, 1990)","url":""}]},{"id":"five-elements","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/five-elements/","code":"FT·SCI·013","name":"Five Elements","aliases":["Jungwa Nga","'Byung ba lnga","Five great elements","Pancha Mahabhuta","Elements in Tibetan thought"],"tibetan":"འབྱུང་བ་ལྔ","wylie":"'byung ba lnga","sanskrit":"Pañcamahābhūta","category":"Cosmology","era":"","summary":"Tibetan thought describes the physical world through five elements, earth, water, fire, wind and space, alongside a second, Chinese-derived set used in astrology.","body":["The five elements are the basic categories through which Tibetan Buddhist, medical and astrological traditions describe matter. In the principal scheme, inherited from India, they are earth, water, fire, wind and space. They are defined by properties, not by substance: earth is solidity, water cohesion and fluidity, fire heat, wind motion, and space the openness that allows the others to exist. Everything material, from a mountain to a human body, is analysed as a combination of them.","The elements structure cosmology and the account of death. Buddhist texts describe a world system forming as wind, fire, water and earth arise in sequence within space, and dissolving in the reverse order at the end of an age. The dying person is said to experience a parallel dissolution, earth into water, water into fire, fire into wind and wind into consciousness. In art each element has a colour and shape, stacked in the form of the stupa.","A second set of five, wood, fire, earth, iron and water, reached Tibet from China and is used in astrology and the naming of years. The two systems serve different purposes and are kept distinct. The Bon tradition gives the elements a central place in its rituals of healing. Dialogues between Tibetan scholars and physicists have compared element theory with modern accounts of matter, generally treating it as a classification of qualities and not a rival chemistry."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Jungwa nga"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian Buddhist doctrine of the great elements"},{"label":"Elements","value":"Earth, water, fire, wind, space"},{"label":"Properties","value":"Solidity, fluidity, heat, motion, openness"},{"label":"Colours and shapes","value":"Yellow square, white circle, red triangle, green crescent, blue drop"},{"label":"Second system","value":"Wood, fire, earth, iron, water (Chinese-derived, in astrology)"}],"related":["medicine/five-elements-in-medicine","science/naktsi","science/abhidharma-cosmology","science/kalachakra-cosmology","symbols/stupa","concepts/bardo","science/twelve-animals-and-five-elements","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","symbols/sipaho","symbols/prayer-flags","science/mewa-and-parkha","concepts/rainbow-body"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mahabhuta — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mah%C4%81bh%C5%ABta"},{"title":"Alexander Berzin, Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma and Kalachakra — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/abhidharma-tenet-systems/time-the-universe/buddhist-cosmology-in-abhidharma-and-kalachakra"},{"title":"Jamgon Kongtrul, Myriad Worlds: Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma, Kalacakra and Dzog-chen (Snow Lion, 1995)","url":""}]},{"id":"mount-meru","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/mount-meru/","code":"FT·SCI·014","name":"Mount Meru","aliases":["Sumeru","Rirab","Ri rab lhunpo","Mount Sumeru","Sineru"],"tibetan":"རི་རབ","wylie":"ri rab","sanskrit":"Sumeru","category":"Cosmology","era":"","summary":"Mount Meru is the vast mountain at the centre of the world in classical Buddhist cosmology, ringed by seas, mountain ranges and four continents.","body":["Mount Meru, or Sumeru, is the axis of the world in the cosmology that Tibetan Buddhism inherited from India. It rises from the centre of a great ocean, with the sun, moon and stars circling it. Human beings live on Jambudvipa, the continent to its south. The image organises Buddhist thinking about space, the heavens and the realms of rebirth, and it is reproduced constantly in ritual, art and architecture.","In the account of Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakosha, Meru stands 80,000 yojanas above the ocean and extends as far below it. It has four faces of precious substances, the southern one of blue beryl, whose reflection is said to colour the sky of our continent. Seven rings of golden mountains and seas surround it, and beyond them lie four continents, each flanked by two smaller ones. The gods of the Heaven of the Thirty-Three dwell on its summit. The Kalachakra Tantra gives a different shape and measurements.","The mandala offering, performed daily by Tibetan Buddhists, presents the whole Meru universe in symbolic form, and the monastery of Samye was laid out on its plan in the eighth century. Mount Kailash in western Tibet is often associated with it. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama has said that the literal Meru cosmology is contradicted by observation and should be set aside, while its symbolic and ritual uses continue."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Rirab (Rirab Lhunpo)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian cosmology, shared by Buddhist, Hindu and Jain traditions"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Abhidharmakosha, chapter 3; Kalachakra Tantra, chapter 1"},{"label":"Height","value":"80,000 yojanas above the sea (Abhidharma); 100,000 (Kalachakra)"},{"label":"Surroundings","value":"Seven golden ranges and seas; four continents; eight subcontinents"},{"label":"Human continent","value":"Jambudvipa, to the south"},{"label":"Ritual use","value":"Mandala offering; plan of Samye monastery"}],"related":["science/abhidharma-cosmology","science/kalachakra-cosmology","symbols/mandala","places/samye","places/mount-kailash","concepts/six-realms","deities/four-guardian-kings","science/dalai-lama-and-science","symbols/victory-banner","symbols/seven-royal-emblems","symbols/mandala-offering","symbols/double-vajra","symbols/tenfold-powerful-one","history/samye-founded","texts/abhidharmakosha"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mount Meru (Buddhism) — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Meru_(Buddhism)"},{"title":"Alexander Berzin, Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma and Kalachakra — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/abhidharma-tenet-systems/time-the-universe/buddhist-cosmology-in-abhidharma-and-kalachakra"},{"title":"Akira Sadakata, Buddhist Cosmology: Philosophy and Origins (Kosei Publishing, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"abhidharma-cosmology","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/abhidharma-cosmology/","code":"FT·SCI·015","name":"Abhidharma Cosmology","aliases":["Abhidharmakosha cosmology","Buddhist cosmology","Ngonpa cosmology","Meru world system","Trichiliocosm"],"tibetan":"ཆོས་མངོན་པ","wylie":"chos mngon pa","sanskrit":"Abhidharma","category":"Cosmology","era":"4th–5th century text","summary":"Abhidharma cosmology is the classical Buddhist model of the universe, set out by Vasubandhu, with Mount Meru at the centre of each of countless world systems.","body":["The cosmology of the Abhidharma is the standard picture of the universe studied in Tibetan monastic colleges. Its main source is the third chapter of the Abhidharmakosha, the Treasury of Abhidharma, composed by the Indian master Vasubandhu in the fourth or fifth century. The text is one of the five great subjects of the Gelug curriculum and is studied in every Tibetan school, so that generations of scholars have known its measurements by heart.","A world system rests on a disc of wind, above which lie water and a golden ground. At the centre stands Mount Meru, encircled by seven ranges and seas, then four continents and an outer wall of iron mountains. Beings occupy three realms, of desire, form and formlessness, arranged from hells below the earth to heavens above the mountain. A thousand such worlds make a small universe, and a thousand cubed, a billion, make the ‘great thousandfold’ universe, of which there are countless.","Time is cyclical. Each universe passes through four phases of formation, duration, destruction and emptiness, together making one great aeon. Buddhist writers treated the system as a map of the conditions of rebirth as much as a geography. Tibetan authors such as Jamgon Kongtrul noted that different scriptures give different cosmologies for different audiences. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama has written that its physical details must yield to modern astronomy, while its vision of many worlds and vast timescales remains instructive."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Ngonpa (Abhidharma); Ngonpa Dzo (Abhidharmakosha)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian Buddhist scholasticism"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Vasubandhu (4th–5th century)"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Abhidharmakosha, chapter 3, on the world"},{"label":"Structure","value":"Wind, water and golden ground; Meru; four continents; three realms"},{"label":"Scale","value":"A billion world systems form one 'great thousandfold' universe"},{"label":"Time","value":"Four phases: formation, duration, destruction, emptiness"}],"related":["science/mount-meru","science/kalachakra-cosmology","concepts/six-realms","science/five-elements","texts/treasury-of-knowledge","concepts/samsara","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Buddhist cosmology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_cosmology"},{"title":"Alexander Berzin, Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma and Kalachakra — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/abhidharma-tenet-systems/time-the-universe/buddhist-cosmology-in-abhidharma-and-kalachakra"},{"title":"Jamgon Kongtrul, Myriad Worlds: Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma, Kalacakra and Dzog-chen (Snow Lion, 1995)","url":""}]},{"id":"kalachakra-cosmology","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/kalachakra-cosmology/","code":"FT·SCI·016","name":"Kalachakra Cosmology","aliases":["Outer Kalachakra","Wheel of Time cosmology","Dukhor cosmology","Kalacakra world system"],"tibetan":"དུས་ཀྱི་འཁོར་ལོ","wylie":"dus kyi 'khor lo","sanskrit":"Kālacakra","category":"Cosmology","era":"11th century text","summary":"The Kalachakra Tantra presents a cosmos of stacked elemental discs and a round Mount Meru, designed to mirror the human body and to serve as a basis for astronomy.","body":["The Kalachakra, or Wheel of Time, Tantra appeared in India in the early eleventh century and was soon translated into Tibetan. Its first chapter describes the universe. This ‘outer Kalachakra’ differs in many particulars from the older Abhidharma model, and it has had practical importance in Tibet because the Tibetan calendar and astronomical calculation are derived from it. It is studied especially in the Jonang, Gelug, Sakya and Kagyu schools.","The Kalachakra world rests on four discs, of wind, fire, water and earth, each 50,000 yojanas thick. Their diameters are 400,000, 300,000, 200,000 and 100,000 yojanas, so that each projects beyond the one above. On the earth disc stands a round Mount Meru 100,000 yojanas high, wider at the top than at the base, surrounded by rings of continents, seas and mountains. The planets move in the wind above, along tracks that the text uses to explain the seasons and the lengths of days.","The system’s organising idea is correspondence: the proportions of the cosmos match those of the human body and of the Kalachakra mandala, which are termed outer, inner and other. Tibetan scholars were aware that the two cosmologies disagree; many concluded that each was taught for a purpose and that neither need be taken as a literal survey. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, who has conferred the Kalachakra initiation many times, has made the same point in his writings on science."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Dukyi Khorlo (Dukhor)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"India, early 11th century"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Kalachakra Tantra, chapter 1; Stainless Light commentary"},{"label":"Discs","value":"Wind, fire, water, earth: 400,000 to 100,000 yojanas across"},{"label":"Mount Meru","value":"Round; 100,000 yojanas high"},{"label":"Method","value":"Correspondence of outer (cosmos), inner (body) and other (practice)"},{"label":"Use","value":"Basis of the Tibetan calendar and astronomy"}],"related":["deities/kalachakra","texts/kalachakra-tantra","science/abhidharma-cosmology","science/mount-meru","science/kartsi","science/tibetan-calendar","science/five-elements","schools/jonang","symbols/tenfold-powerful-one","symbols/sipaho","science/lunar-mansions","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","history/kalachakra-and-first-rabjung-cycle","texts/treasury-of-knowledge"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Alexander Berzin, Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma and Kalachakra — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/abhidharma-tenet-systems/time-the-universe/buddhist-cosmology-in-abhidharma-and-kalachakra"},{"title":"Outer Kalachakra — International Kalachakra Network","url":"https://kalachakranet.org/kt_outer_kalachakra.html"},{"title":"Jamgon Kongtrul, Myriad Worlds: Buddhist Cosmology in Abhidharma, Kalacakra and Dzog-chen (Snow Lion, 1995)","url":""}]},{"id":"atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy/","code":"FT·SCI·017","name":"Atomism in Buddhist Philosophy","aliases":["Buddhist atomism","Partless particles","Dul tren","Paramanu","Subtle particles"],"tibetan":"རྡུལ་ཕྲ་རབ","wylie":"rdul phra rab","sanskrit":"Paramāṇu","category":"Cosmology","era":"","summary":"Indian Buddhist schools proposed that matter is built of minute particles, and later philosophers argued that no particle can be truly indivisible.","body":["Buddhist philosophy developed theories of the smallest constituents of matter in the early centuries of the common era. The Vaibhashika and Sautrantika schools of Indian Buddhism held that physical things are aggregates of extremely subtle particles, each lasting only an instant. Tibetan scholars study these positions as part of the graded survey of philosophical systems, and they form the classical Buddhist contribution to questions that modern physics also addresses.","In the Abhidharma account the smallest unit of matter in the realm of the senses is a cluster of eight components: the four elements of earth, water, fire and wind, and the qualities of visible form, smell, taste and touch. The Vaibhashikas regarded the ultimate particle as partless. Vasubandhu, in his Twenty Verses, objected that a particle joined to others on six sides must have six sides and therefore parts, and Madhyamaka thinkers extended the argument to deny any irreducible basis of matter.","The Kalachakra Tantra adds the idea of ‘space particles’ that persist between the destruction of one universe and the formation of the next. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama examines the idea in his 2005 book on science, The Universe in a Single Atom, and has discussed it with physicists at the Mind and Life dialogues. He and other commentators stress that Buddhist atomism was reached by reasoning, without experiment, and that parallels with quantum physics are suggestive analogies, not equivalences."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Dul tra rab"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Most subtle particle"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian Abhidharma schools: Vaibhashika and Sautrantika"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Vasubandhu; Dignaga; Madhyamaka critics"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Abhidharmakosha; Twenty Verses (Vimshatika)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Analysis by reasoning into parts and moments"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Later schools reject any partless, independently existing particle"}],"related":["science/abhidharma-cosmology","science/kalachakra-cosmology","concepts/emptiness","concepts/two-truths","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/five-elements","science/pramana","science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Buddhist atomism — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_atomism"},{"title":"Dalai Lama, The Universe in a Single Atom: The Convergence of Science and Spirituality (Morgan Road Books, 2005)","url":""},{"title":"Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics, Vol. 1: The Physical World, ed. Thupten Jinpa (Wisdom Publications, 2017)","url":""}]},{"id":"pramana","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/pramana/","code":"FT·SCI·018","name":"Pramana","aliases":["Tsema","Tshad ma","Valid cognition","Buddhist epistemology","Buddhist logic"],"tibetan":"ཚད་མ","wylie":"tshad ma","sanskrit":"Pramāṇa","category":"Logic & Epistemology","era":"from the 5th–7th centuries","summary":"Pramana, ‘valid cognition’, is the Buddhist theory of knowledge founded by Dignaga and Dharmakirti, which recognises two reliable sources: perception and inference.","body":["Pramana is the branch of Buddhist philosophy that asks what counts as knowledge and how it is obtained. The Sanskrit word means a measure or a reliable means of knowing; the Tibetan equivalent is tsema. The discipline was founded in India by Dignaga and developed by Dharmakirti, and in Tibet it became the training ground of monastic education, the subject through which students learn to reason and to debate.","The system accepts two kinds of valid cognition. Direct perception grasps particular, momentary things without the mediation of concepts. Inference knows what is hidden from the senses through a sound reason, as fire is known from smoke. A reason is sound when it meets three criteria relating the reason to the subject and to similar and dissimilar cases. Scripture is not an independent source of knowledge; it may be relied upon only where it has passed tests of consistency with perception and inference.","Translation and study of these works at Sangphu monastery from the late eleventh century created a distinctive Tibetan tradition. Sakya Pandita’s Treasury of Reasoning, written about 1219, criticised earlier Tibetan interpretations, and Gelug authors later wrote extensive commentaries. Dharmakirti’s Commentary on Valid Cognition is one of the five great texts of the Gelug curriculum. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama often cites this tradition’s insistence on evidence and reasoning as common ground with science."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Tsema"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Valid cognition; reliable means of knowledge"},{"label":"Origin","value":"India, 5th–7th centuries"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Dignaga, Dharmakirti, Sakya Pandita, Gyaltsab Je"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Pramanavarttika (Commentary on Valid Cognition)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Two sources of knowledge: direct perception and inference"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Sangphu monastery; Gelug and Sakya monastic colleges"}],"related":["science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga","science/monastic-debate","science/collected-topics","science/science-of-mind","masters/sakya-pandita","science/five-sciences","schools/gelug","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","science/ten-sciences","masters/shantarakshita","texts/pramanavarttika"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Buddhist logico-epistemology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_logico-epistemology"},{"title":"Dharmakirti — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dharmakiirti/"},{"title":"Georges Dreyfus, Recognizing Reality: Dharmakirti's Philosophy and Its Tibetan Interpretations (State University of New York Press, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"dharmakirti-and-dignaga","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga/","code":"FT·SCI·019","name":"Dharmakirti and Dignaga","aliases":["Dignaga and Dharmakirti","Chokyi Drakpa","Chogyi Langpo","Founders of Buddhist logic","Dignaga","Dharmakirti"],"tibetan":"ཕྱོགས་གླང་དང་ཆོས་གྲགས","wylie":"phyogs glang dang chos grags","sanskrit":"Dignāga, Dharmakīrti","category":"Logic & Epistemology","era":"c. 480–540 and c. 600–660","summary":"Dignaga and Dharmakirti were the Indian philosophers who founded Buddhist logic and epistemology, whose works became the core of Tibetan training in reasoning.","body":["Dignaga and Dharmakirti are the two founders of the Buddhist tradition of logic and theory of knowledge. Dignaga, usually dated about 480 to 540, was a scholar from South India whom tradition makes a student of Vasubandhu. Dharmakirti, conventionally dated about 600 to 660 though some scholars place him earlier, reworked and defended Dignaga’s system. Tibetans count both among the ‘six ornaments’ of India, the greatest Indian Buddhist masters.","Dignaga’s Compendium of Valid Cognition reduced the sources of knowledge to perception and inference, defined the three marks of a valid reason and proposed that words refer by excluding what a thing is not. Dharmakirti wrote seven treatises, of which the Commentary on Valid Cognition is the most studied. He grounded inference in real relations of causality and identity, defined the real as that which can produce effects, and argued for rebirth, the Buddha’s authority and the momentariness of all things.","Their Sanskrit works were largely lost in India and survived in Tibetan translation; Sanskrit manuscripts of several were rediscovered in Tibetan monasteries in the 1930s by the Indian scholar Rahul Sankrityayan. In Tibet their thought was received through the school of Sangphu and has been taught without interruption in the monastic colleges. Their arguments are the subject of active research in philosophy departments, where Dharmakirti in particular is read as a major figure in the history of epistemology."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Chokyi Langpo (Dignaga); Chokyi Drakpa (Dharmakirti)"},{"label":"Period","value":"Dignaga c. 480–540; Dharmakirti c. 600–660 (dates debated)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"India; both associated with the south and with Nalanda"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Pramanasamuccaya (Dignaga); Pramanavarttika (Dharmakirti)"},{"label":"Number","value":"Seven treatises on valid cognition by Dharmakirti"},{"label":"Method","value":"Perception and inference; three criteria of a valid reason"},{"label":"Title","value":"Counted among the six ornaments of India"}],"related":["science/pramana","science/monastic-debate","science/collected-topics","science/science-of-mind","masters/nagarjuna","masters/sakya-pandita","texts/tengyur","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Dharmakirti — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy","url":"https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dharmakiirti/"},{"title":"Dharmakirti — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dharmakirti"},{"title":"Dignaga — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dign%C4%81ga"},{"title":"Georges Dreyfus, Recognizing Reality: Dharmakirti's Philosophy and Its Tibetan Interpretations (State University of New York Press, 1997)","url":""}]},{"id":"monastic-debate","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/monastic-debate/","code":"FT·SCI·020","name":"Monastic Debate","aliases":["Tsopa","rTsod pa","Tibetan debate","Dialectical debate","Tsennyi"],"tibetan":"རྩོད་པ","wylie":"rtsod pa","sanskrit":"Vāda","category":"Logic & Epistemology","era":"from the 12th century","summary":"Monastic debate is the formal, physically animated method of argument through which Tibetan monks and nuns test their understanding of philosophy.","body":["Debate is the characteristic teaching method of Tibetan scholastic education. For several hours a day, students gather in the monastery courtyard to argue points of doctrine in pairs or groups under set rules. The aim is to examine a position until its weaknesses are exposed and its meaning understood, and to train memory, quick reasoning and confidence. The practice is most developed in the Gelug school and is also used in Sakya, Kagyu, Nyingma and Bon colleges.","One party, the defender, sits and maintains a thesis. The other, the challenger, stands and poses questions that draw out consequences of the defender’s answers. The challenger marks each point with a loud clap of the right hand on the left and a stamp of the foot, gestures given symbolic meanings such as closing the door to unfortunate rebirth. The defender may reply only in a few set ways: accepting, asking for a reason, denying that the reason is established, or denying that the consequence follows.","The form grew out of the Indian rules of disputation and took shape at Sangphu monastery in the twelfth century. Advancement through the curriculum depends on performance in debate, and the examinations for the geshe degree are public debates before the assembled monastery. Nuns now follow the same training: the first twenty women to earn the Geshema degree received it from the Dalai Lama in December 2016. Debate has also shaped how Tibetan scholars engage scientists in dialogue."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Tsopa"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian disputation; Tibetan form from Sangphu monastery"},{"label":"Period","value":"12th century to the present"},{"label":"Method","value":"Seated defender answers a standing challenger within fixed forms of reply"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Chapa Chokyi Sengge (1109–1169); Tsongkhapa"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Debate courtyards of Drepung, Sera, Ganden and other colleges"},{"label":"Recent milestone","value":"First Geshema degrees for nuns, December 2016"}],"related":["science/collected-topics","science/pramana","science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga","schools/gelug","places/sera","places/drepung","places/ganden","science/science-of-mind","science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","science/science-for-monks","masters/chandrakirti","masters/sakya-pandita","masters/nyammed-sherab-gyaltsen","places/menri-monastery","places/larung-gar","places/labrang","places/bylakuppe","texts/pramanavarttika","concepts/geshe"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Alexander Berzin, The Gelug Monastic Education System — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/history-culture/monasteries-in-tibet/the-gelug-monastic-education-system"},{"title":"Ceremony to Award Nuns the First Geshe-ma Degrees — Office of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, 2016","url":"https://dalailama.com/news/2016/ceremony-to-award-nuns-the-first-geshe-ma-degrees-golden-jubilee-of-cst-mundgod"},{"title":"Georges Dreyfus, The Sound of Two Hands Clapping: The Education of a Tibetan Buddhist Monk (University of California Press, 2003)","url":""},{"title":"Daniel Perdue, Debate in Tibetan Buddhism (Snow Lion, 1992)","url":""}]},{"id":"collected-topics","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/collected-topics/","code":"FT·SCI·021","name":"Collected Topics","aliases":["Dura","Dudra","bsDus grwa","Collected Topics of Valid Cognition","Geshe curriculum"],"tibetan":"བསྡུས་གྲྭ","wylie":"bsdus grwa","sanskrit":"","category":"Logic & Epistemology","era":"from the 12th century","summary":"The Collected Topics, or Dura, is the introductory course in logic and debate that opens the long Tibetan monastic curriculum leading to the geshe degree.","body":["The Collected Topics is the first stage of philosophical study in Tibetan monastic colleges. Its Tibetan name, dura, means a class on condensed material: the subjects are drawn from the Indian treatises on valid cognition and reduced to a form suitable for beginners. Through it young monks and nuns learn the vocabulary of philosophy and the procedure of formal debate. The genre is traced to Chapa Chokyi Sengge (1109–1169), abbot of Sangphu monastery, who is credited with eighteen such topics.","The course has three parts. The Collected Topics proper begins with simple matters, traditionally colours, and proceeds to existents and non-existents, identity and difference, cause and effect, and generalities and particulars, each practised as a set of debates. ‘Awareness and knowledge’ classifies types of mind, and ‘signs and reasoning’ teaches the forms of valid and invalid proof. Widely used manuals include those of the Rato tradition and of Purbuchok Jampa Gyatso (1825–1901), tutor to the Thirteenth Dalai Lama.","After these preliminaries, students in the Gelug school spend about two decades on five great subjects, each based on an Indian text: valid cognition, the perfection of wisdom, the Middle Way, Abhidharma and monastic discipline. Those who complete the course and its examinations earn the title of geshe, of which Lharampa is the highest rank. Since 2014 modern science has been taught beside this curriculum in the major Gelug monastic universities in India."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Dura (Dudra)"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Class on collected (condensed) topics"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Sangphu monastery, central Tibet"},{"label":"Period","value":"12th century to the present"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Chapa Chokyi Sengge (1109–1169); Purbuchok Jampa Gyatso (1825–1901)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Three stages: collected topics, awareness and knowledge, signs and reasoning"},{"label":"Leads to","value":"Five great texts and the geshe degree (highest rank: Lharampa)"}],"related":["science/monastic-debate","science/pramana","science/science-of-mind","science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga","schools/gelug","places/drepung","places/sera","science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","science/science-for-monks"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Bsdus grwa — Encyclopedia of Buddhism","url":"https://encyclopediaofbuddhism.org/wiki/Bsdus_grwa"},{"title":"Alexander Berzin, The Gelug Monastic Education System — Study Buddhism","url":"https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/history-culture/monasteries-in-tibet/the-gelug-monastic-education-system"},{"title":"Daniel Perdue, Debate in Tibetan Buddhism (Snow Lion, 1992)","url":""},{"title":"Georges Dreyfus, The Sound of Two Hands Clapping: The Education of a Tibetan Buddhist Monk (University of California Press, 2003)","url":""}]},{"id":"science-of-mind","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/science-of-mind/","code":"FT·SCI·022","name":"Science of Mind (Lorig)","aliases":["Lorig","Lorik","Blo rig","Awareness and knowledge","Buddhist psychology","Mind and awareness"],"tibetan":"བློ་རིག","wylie":"blo rig","sanskrit":"","category":"Logic & Epistemology","era":"","summary":"Lorig, ‘awareness and knowledge’, is the Tibetan monastic study of the mind, which defines consciousness and classifies its valid and mistaken forms.","body":["Lorig is the part of the monastic curriculum devoted to the nature and types of mind. It is studied early, after the Collected Topics, and provides the psychological vocabulary used in all later study. The subject draws its theory of knowledge from Dharmakirti and its analysis of mental states from the Abhidharma. It is the body of Tibetan learning that most directly meets cognitive science, and it has been a regular topic of dialogue between scholars and scientists.","Mind is defined as that which is clear and knowing. Lorig manuals divide awareness in several ways, the best known being a sevenfold scheme: direct perception, inference, subsequent cognition, correct assumption, inattentive perception, doubt and wrong cognition. Only the first two are fully valid sources of new knowledge. A further division separates six primary consciousnesses, of the five senses and the mind, from the mental factors that accompany them, of which the standard list has fifty-one.","The mental factors include attention, feeling and intention, wholesome states such as conscientiousness, and afflictions such as anger and jealousy, each given a definition and a function. This taxonomy underlies Buddhist methods for training attention and emotion. Presentations for a wider audience include a 1980 translation of a Gelug manual with commentary by Lati Rinpoche and the 2020 volume on mind in the series Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics, compiled at the Dalai Lama’s direction."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Lorig"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Awareness and knowledge"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Dharmakirti's epistemology and Abhidharma psychology"},{"label":"Definition of mind","value":"That which is clear and knowing"},{"label":"Method","value":"Sevenfold division of awareness; primary minds and mental factors"},{"label":"Number","value":"6 primary consciousnesses; 51 mental factors"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Lati Rinbochay and Napper, Mind in Tibetan Buddhism (1980)"}],"related":["science/collected-topics","science/pramana","science/dharmakirti-and-dignaga","science/monastic-debate","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/dalai-lama-and-science","concepts/lojong","science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mental factors (Buddhism) — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_factors_(Buddhism)"},{"title":"Lati Rinbochay and Elizabeth Napper, Mind in Tibetan Buddhism (Snow Lion, 1980)","url":""},{"title":"Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics, Vol. 2: The Mind, ed. Thupten Jinpa (Wisdom Publications, 2020)","url":""}]},{"id":"five-sciences","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/five-sciences/","code":"FT·SCI·023","name":"Five Sciences","aliases":["Five major sciences","Rigne nga","Rig gnas lnga","Pancavidya","Five fields of knowledge"],"tibetan":"རིག་གནས་ལྔ","wylie":"rig gnas lnga","sanskrit":"Pañcavidyā","category":"Classical Sciences","era":"","summary":"The five sciences are the major fields of classical Indo-Tibetan learning: arts and crafts, medicine, grammar, logic and the inner science of Buddhism.","body":["The five sciences are the framework within which Tibetan tradition organises knowledge. Inherited from Indian Mahayana Buddhism, the scheme names five fields that a learned person should master: the arts and crafts, medicine, grammar, logic and the ‘inner science’, meaning Buddhist doctrine and practice. The Tibetan term, rigne, literally ‘fields of knowing’, is also the modern Tibetan word for culture. The title pandita was reserved for scholars accomplished in all five.","An Indian Mahayana treatise attributed to Maitreya states that without diligence in the five sciences even the most advanced bodhisattva cannot attain omniscience. The first four are called common sciences because they are shared with non-Buddhists. Logic and grammar are studied to correct error, medicine and the crafts to benefit others, and the inner science for one’s own realisation. Medicine in this scheme is Sowa Rigpa; the crafts include painting, sculpture, metalwork and building.","The scheme shaped the Tibetan canon of translated treatises, the Tengyur, whose later volumes are arranged by science. Sakya Pandita in the thirteenth century was the first Tibetan to be recognised as a master of the five, and he promoted them as the proper scope of scholarship. A further five ‘minor’ sciences were added to make ten. Institutes of Tibetan studies in Tibet, India and Bhutan still organise departments on this model."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Rigne nga (rigne chewa nga)"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Five (major) fields of knowledge"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian Mahayana Buddhism"},{"label":"The five","value":"Arts and crafts, medicine, grammar, logic, inner science"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Mahayanasutralamkara (Ornament of the Mahayana Sutras)"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Sakya Pandita (1182–1251)"},{"label":"Extended as","value":"Ten sciences, with five minor fields"}],"related":["science/ten-sciences","medicine/sowa-rigpa","science/pramana","science/tibetan-grammar-and-linguistics","masters/sakya-pandita","texts/tengyur","symbols/iconometry","science/tibetan-astrology","deities/sarasvati","science/tibetan-architecture-and-engineering","masters/situ-panchen","masters/thonmi-sambhota","places/larung-gar","texts/pramanavarttika","texts/treasury-of-knowledge","texts/uchen-and-ume-scripts","texts/mahavyutpatti"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Sakya Pandita — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya_Pandita"},{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Jonathan C. Gold, The Dharma's Gatekeepers: Sakya Pandita on Buddhist Scholarship in Tibet (State University of New York Press, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"ten-sciences","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/ten-sciences/","code":"FT·SCI·024","name":"Ten Sciences","aliases":["Rigne chu","Rig gnas bcu","Ten fields of knowledge","Five major and five minor sciences","Dashavidya"],"tibetan":"རིག་གནས་བཅུ","wylie":"rig gnas bcu","sanskrit":"Daśavidyā","category":"Classical Sciences","era":"established in Tibet in the 13th century","summary":"The ten sciences are the five major and five minor fields of knowledge that defined a complete education in classical Tibetan scholarship.","body":["The ten sciences are the full classical curriculum of the Tibetan scholar. They consist of the five major sciences, arts and crafts, medicine, grammar, logic and Buddhist doctrine, and five minor sciences: poetics, prosody, lexicography, drama and astrology. The minor fields are mostly literary. They were treated as extensions of grammar, since their purpose was to equip a scholar to read and compose in the manner of the Indian classics.","Each minor science rests on an Indian model. Poetics follows Dandin’s Mirror of Poetry, which sets out figures of speech and styles. Prosody teaches the metres of Sanskrit verse. Lexicography is the study of synonyms, based on dictionaries such as the Amarakosha. Drama was known through translated plays and theory, though it never became a staged court art in Tibet. Astrology, or calculation, covers the calendar, astronomy and divination described in the Kalachakra and related systems.","The minor sciences became established in Tibet during the thirteenth century through the work of Sakya Pandita and of translators at Sakya, who rendered the Mirror of Poetry into Tibetan. Ornate poetry on the Indian model then became a mark of learning, and remained so into the twentieth century. The Fifth Dalai Lama and his regent Desi Sangye Gyatso were noted patrons of all ten. The scheme survives in the syllabuses of Tibetan-language university departments."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Rigne chu"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Ten fields of knowledge"},{"label":"Major five","value":"Arts and crafts, medicine, grammar, logic, inner science"},{"label":"Minor five","value":"Poetics, prosody, lexicography, drama, astrology"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian scholastic tradition"},{"label":"Period","value":"Established in Tibet in the 13th century"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Sakya Pandita (1182–1251); Fifth Dalai Lama; Desi Sangye Gyatso"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Dandin's Mirror of Poetry (Kavyadarsha) for poetics"}],"related":["science/five-sciences","masters/sakya-pandita","science/tibetan-astrology","science/tibetan-grammar-and-linguistics","medicine/sowa-rigpa","science/pramana","masters/fifth-dalai-lama","masters/desi-sangye-gyatso","science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan astrology — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_astrology"},{"title":"Sakya Pandita — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya_Pandita"},{"title":"Jonathan C. Gold, The Dharma's Gatekeepers: Sakya Pandita on Buddhist Scholarship in Tibet (State University of New York Press, 2007)","url":""},{"title":"Jose Ignacio Cabezon and Roger R. Jackson (eds.), Tibetan Literature: Studies in Genre (Snow Lion, 1996)","url":""}]},{"id":"tibetan-grammar-and-linguistics","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-grammar-and-linguistics/","code":"FT·SCI·025","name":"Tibetan Grammar and Linguistics","aliases":["Sumtak","Sum rtags","Science of language","Dra rigpa","Sumchupa and Takjuk","Tibetan grammatical tradition"],"tibetan":"བརྡ་སྤྲོད","wylie":"brda sprod","sanskrit":"Śabdavidyā","category":"Classical Sciences","era":"from the 7th century, by tradition","summary":"The Tibetan grammatical tradition rests on two short verse treatises attributed to Thonmi Sambhota and on centuries of commentary explaining the written language.","body":["Grammar, the science of language, is one of the five major sciences and the first formal subject a Tibetan student meets after learning to read. The native tradition is built on two brief treatises in verse, the Thirty Verses and the Guide to Signs, known together as Sumtak. Tradition ascribes them to Thonmi Sambhota, the minister who is said to have devised the Tibetan script in the seventh century after studying in India.","The Thirty Verses describes the alphabet of thirty consonants and four vowel signs and the use of the particles that mark grammatical case, modelled in part on the eight cases of Sanskrit. The Guide to Signs classifies letters as masculine, feminine or neuter according to their sound and explains how prefixed and suffixed letters relate to verb forms. Modern scholars question the traditional dating and single authorship of the two works, which describe the language in a relatively developed state.","Translation from Sanskrit prompted further linguistic work. In the early ninth century royal commissions compiled a Sanskrit-Tibetan glossary, the Mahavyutpatti, and fixed rules for coining terms. Later scholars wrote spelling dictionaries and commentaries, of which the eighteenth-century Great Commentary of Situ Panchen is the most authoritative. A short mnemonic poem by Yangchen Drubpai Dorje is still memorised in schools. Linguists now also study the spoken Tibetic languages, which differ widely from the classical written form."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Da tro (grammar); Sumtak (the two root texts)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Tibetan composition on Indian grammatical models"},{"label":"Period","value":"7th century by tradition; dating debated"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Thonmi Sambhota; Situ Panchen Chokyi Jungne (1700–1774)"},{"label":"Key text","value":"Sumchupa (Thirty Verses); Takkyi Jukpa (Guide to Signs)"},{"label":"Script","value":"30 consonants and 4 vowel signs"},{"label":"Related work","value":"Mahavyutpatti, Sanskrit-Tibetan glossary, early 9th century"}],"related":["masters/thonmi-sambhota","texts/tibetan-script","science/five-sciences","science/ten-sciences","masters/songtsen-gampo","texts/kangyur","texts/tengyur","masters/sakya-pandita"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Thonmi Sambhota — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thonmi_Sambhota"},{"title":"Mahavyutpatti — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahavyutpatti"},{"title":"Yangchen Drubpe Dorje, The Magical Wish-Fulfilling Tree — Lotsawa House","url":"https://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan-masters/yangchen-drubpe-dorje/magical-wish-fulfilling-tree"},{"title":"Roy Andrew Miller, Studies in the Grammatical Tradition in Tibet (John Benjamins, 1976)","url":""}]},{"id":"tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-mathematics-and-sand-abacus/","code":"FT·SCI·026","name":"Tibetan Mathematics and the Sand Abacus","aliases":["Sand abacus","Sa zhong","Sa gzhong","Sand board calculation","Tibetan arithmetic","Tsi"],"tibetan":"ས་གཞོང","wylie":"sa gzhong","sanskrit":"","category":"Classical Sciences","era":"","summary":"Tibetan mathematics developed as a practical art of calculation for calendar-making and accounts, performed with a stylus on a wooden board dusted with sand.","body":["Mathematics in traditional Tibet was a working skill more than a theoretical subject. The Tibetan word for it, tsi, means reckoning, and it covers arithmetic, calendar computation and astronomy without distinction. Its principal uses were the yearly calculation of the calendar and almanac and the keeping of government and monastic accounts. No tradition of geometrical proof developed, though exact proportion was important in the related crafts of image-making and building.","Calendar calculations were carried out on a sand board: a long, shallow wooden tray spread with fine sand or dust, on which figures were written with a pointed stick and wiped away as the work advanced. Numbers were written in decimal place value with a zero, in numerals of Indian origin. The astronomer worked through long chains of multiplication and division in mixed units, such as sixty-part subdivisions of the day, memorising the constants and procedures and keeping only the result.","Texts record numbers in a learned code inherited from India, in which words stand for digits: ‘moon’ for one, ‘eyes’ for two, ‘fire’ for three, and so on. For accounts, officials also reckoned with counters such as pebbles and sticks laid out in columns. Astrologers at the Mentsikhang institutes continue to learn sand-board calculation, although computers now do most of the routine work. The historical methods have been reconstructed by Dieter Schuh, Edward Henning and Svante Janson."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Sa zhong (sand board); tsi (calculation)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Indian arithmetic and astronomy, adapted in Tibet"},{"label":"Method","value":"Figures written in sand with a stylus and erased step by step"},{"label":"Number system","value":"Decimal place value with zero; word-numerals in texts"},{"label":"Used for","value":"Calendar, almanac and eclipse calculation; accounts"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Mentsikhang, Lhasa; Men-Tsee-Khang, Dharamsala"}],"related":["science/kartsi","science/tibetan-calendar","science/tibetan-almanac","science/eclipse-calculation","science/tibetan-astrology","symbols/iconometry","medicine/men-tsee-khang","science/ten-sciences"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Introduction to Tibetan Astro-Science — Men-Tsee-Khang","url":"https://mentseekhang.org/introduction-to-tibetan-astrology/"},{"title":"Dieter Schuh, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der tibetischen Kalenderrechnung (Franz Steiner Verlag, 1973)","url":""},{"title":"Edward Henning, Kalacakra and the Tibetan Calendar (American Institute of Buddhist Studies, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"tibetan-architecture-and-engineering","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-architecture-and-engineering/","code":"FT·SCI·027","name":"Tibetan Architecture and Engineering","aliases":["Tibetan building tradition","Iron chain bridges","Chakzam","Tibetan construction","Thangtong Gyalpo's bridges"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Classical Sciences","era":"7th century to the present","summary":"Tibetan builders developed massive inward-sloping walls, timber-framed interiors and, in the fifteenth century, long iron chain suspension bridges.","body":["Building belongs to the science of arts and crafts in the classical Tibetan scheme of knowledge. Tibetan architecture is adapted to a high, dry, earthquake-prone land with little timber. Its typical structure is a thick wall of stone, sun-dried brick or rammed earth, sloping inward as it rises, enclosing a frame of wooden pillars and beams that carries flat roofs of beaten clay. The form is shared by farmhouses, forts, monasteries and palaces.","The inward slope lowers the centre of gravity and helps walls resist tremors. Upper walls are often finished with a dark red band of bundled tamarisk twigs, which lightens the parapet. Monasteries such as Samye, founded in the eighth century, were laid out as models of the Buddhist cosmos. The largest work in the tradition is the Potala Palace in Lhasa, begun in 1645 and rising thirteen storeys up its hill; its Red Palace was added between 1690 and 1694.","The outstanding engineer of Tibetan history is Thangtong Gyalpo, dated 1385 to 1464 or, in other sources, 1361 to 1485. He is credited with fifty-eight iron chain suspension bridges across Tibet and Bhutan, financed in part by the opera troupe he founded. His bridge over the Yarlung Tsangpo at Chushul, built in 1430, spanned about 150 yards and stood until the mid-twentieth century. Several of his chains survive in Bhutan, where they have been reused in restored bridges."],"facts":[{"label":"Origin","value":"Indigenous Tibetan building, with Indian, Nepalese and Chinese influences"},{"label":"Period","value":"7th century to the present"},{"label":"Method","value":"Battered masonry or rammed-earth walls, timber frame, flat clay roofs"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Thangtong Gyalpo (1385–1464 or 1361–1485)"},{"label":"Bridges","value":"58 iron chain suspension bridges, by tradition"},{"label":"Notable bridge","value":"Chushul Chakzam, Yarlung Tsangpo, 1430; span about 150 yards"},{"label":"Notable building","value":"Potala Palace, begun 1645; 13 storeys"}],"related":["masters/thangtong-gyalpo","places/potala-palace","places/samye","science/five-sciences","places/yumbulagang","places/jokhang","symbols/stupa","places/gyantse-kumbum"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Thang Tong Gyalpo — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thang_Tong_Gyalpo"},{"title":"Chushul Chakzam — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chushul_Chakzam"},{"title":"Potala Palace — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potala_Palace"},{"title":"Cyrus Stearns, King of the Empty Plain: The Tibetan Iron-Bridge Builder Tangtong Gyalpo (Snow Lion, 2007)","url":""}]},{"id":"tummo-research","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tummo-research/","code":"FT·SCI·028","name":"Tummo Research","aliases":["Inner heat research","g-Tummo studies","Tummo and body temperature","Science of tummo"],"tibetan":"གཏུམ་མོ","wylie":"gtum mo","sanskrit":"Caṇḍālī","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"from 1981","summary":"Scientific studies since 1981 have measured body temperature and metabolism in practitioners of tummo, the Tibetan yoga of inner heat, in small field experiments.","body":["Tummo, ‘the fierce one’, is a tantric meditation in which the practitioner generates a sensation of heat in the body through breathing techniques, muscular holds and visualisation. It belongs to the Six Yogas of Naropa and is practised mainly in long retreat. Accounts of yogis warming themselves in the cold drew scientific interest in the twentieth century, and tummo became one of the first Tibetan contemplative practices to be measured with physiological instruments.","The first study, led by Herbert Benson and published in Nature in 1982, recorded rises of up to 8.3 degrees Celsius in the finger and toe temperature of three practitioners in Dharamsala, with no change in core temperature. A 1990 report by the same group on three monks in Sikkim described large voluntary changes in resting metabolism. In 2013 Maria Kozhevnikov and colleagues, working with practitioners in eastern Tibet, reported armpit temperatures rising as high as 38.3 degrees during the forceful breathing phase.","The 2013 study also tested untrained Westerners, who raised their temperature briefly using the breathing technique alone; the authors proposed that breathing produces the heat and visualisation helps sustain it. All of these studies involve very few participants, lack randomised controls and were conducted in the field. They show that practitioners can influence peripheral blood flow and, to some degree, body temperature. They do not support popular claims of extreme feats, which have often been exaggerated in retelling."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Tummo"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Fierce one; inner heat"},{"label":"Method","value":"Skin and core thermometry, metabolic measurement, EEG"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Benson et al., Nature 295 (1982); Kozhevnikov et al., PLoS ONE 8 (2013)"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Finger and toe temperature raised by up to 8.3 °C (1982)"},{"label":"Finding (2013)","value":"Axillary temperature up to 38.3 °C during forceful breathing"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Very small samples; no randomised controls; field conditions"}],"related":["concepts/tummo","science/herbert-benson-tummo-studies","concepts/six-yogas-of-naropa","science/contemplative-neuroscience","medicine/channels-winds-and-drops","masters/milarepa","masters/naropa","science/mind-and-life-dialogues"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Benson et al., Body temperature changes during the practice of g Tum-mo yoga — Nature 295 (1982)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/295234a0"},{"title":"Kozhevnikov et al., Neurocognitive and Somatic Components of Temperature Increases during g-Tummo Meditation: Legend and Reality — PLoS ONE 8 (2013)","url":"https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0058244"},{"title":"Benson et al., Three Case Reports of the Metabolic and Electroencephalographic Changes during Advanced Buddhist Meditation Techniques — Behavioral Medicine 16 (1990)","url":"https://sources.mandala.library.virginia.edu/node/85366"}]},{"id":"herbert-benson-tummo-studies","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/herbert-benson-tummo-studies/","code":"FT·SCI·029","name":"Herbert Benson's Tummo Studies","aliases":["Benson tummo study","Harvard tummo study","Body temperature changes during g Tum-mo yoga","Benson 1982"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"1981–1990","summary":"Harvard cardiologist Herbert Benson made the first physiological measurements of Tibetan tummo meditators in 1981, published in Nature in 1982.","body":["Herbert Benson (1935–2022) was a cardiologist at Harvard Medical School known for describing the ‘relaxation response’, the set of bodily changes that accompany simple meditation. Wishing to study advanced practitioners, he sought the help of the Fourteenth Dalai Lama, whom he met during the Dalai Lama’s visit to Harvard in 1979. With that support his team travelled to Dharamsala in 1981 to examine monks who practised tummo, the yoga of inner heat.","The resulting paper, ‘Body temperature changes during the practice of g Tum-mo yoga’, appeared in Nature on 21 January 1982. Its authors were Benson, John Lehmann, M. S. Malhotra, Ralph Goldman, Jeffrey Hopkins and Mark Epstein. Three practitioners were fitted with temperature sensors. During meditation the temperature of their fingers and toes rose by as much as 8.3 degrees Celsius, while rectal temperature did not change. The authors suggested widening of the blood vessels of the skin as the likely mechanism.","A follow-up report in Behavioral Medicine in 1990 described three monks at Rumtek in Sikkim whose resting oxygen consumption rose by up to 61 per cent and fell by up to 64 per cent during different practices. The team also filmed monks drying wet sheets on their bodies in a cold room. The studies were pioneering but involved three subjects each and no control group, and later popular accounts overstated them, sometimes confusing skin and core temperature."],"facts":[{"label":"Key figures","value":"Herbert Benson (1935–2022), Harvard Medical School"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Nature 295, 234–236 (21 January 1982)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Temperature sensors on three tummo practitioners, Dharamsala, 1981"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Finger and toe temperature up by as much as 8.3 °C; core unchanged"},{"label":"Follow-up","value":"Behavioral Medicine 16 (1990): three monks at Rumtek, Sikkim"},{"label":"Follow-up finding","value":"Oxygen consumption raised up to 61%, lowered up to 64%"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Three subjects per study; no controls; often overstated"}],"related":["science/tummo-research","concepts/tummo","science/contemplative-neuroscience","masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama","science/dalai-lama-and-science","places/dharamsala","concepts/six-yogas-of-naropa","science/richard-davidson-studies"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Benson et al., Body temperature changes during the practice of g Tum-mo yoga — Nature 295 (1982)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/295234a0"},{"title":"Benson et al., Three Case Reports of the Metabolic and Electroencephalographic Changes during Advanced Buddhist Meditation Techniques — Behavioral Medicine 16 (1990)","url":"https://sources.mandala.library.virginia.edu/node/85366"},{"title":"Meditation changes temperatures — Harvard Gazette, 2002","url":"https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2002/04/meditation-changes-temperatures"},{"title":"Herbert Benson — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_Benson"}]},{"id":"contemplative-neuroscience","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/contemplative-neuroscience/","code":"FT·SCI·030","name":"Contemplative Neuroscience","aliases":["Contemplative science","Neuroscience of meditation","Meditation research","Contemplative studies"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"from the 1990s","summary":"Contemplative neuroscience is the study of meditation and related mental training with the tools of brain science, a field shaped by dialogue with Tibetan Buddhism.","body":["Contemplative neuroscience investigates how practices such as focused attention, open awareness and compassion meditation affect the brain and behaviour. It emerged in the 1990s and early 2000s, largely through collaboration between neuroscientists and Tibetan Buddhist practitioners brought together by the Mind and Life dialogues. A public conference with the Dalai Lama at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2003 is often cited as the moment the field gained recognition.","Researchers use electroencephalography, magnetic resonance imaging and behavioural tests, and compare long-term practitioners with novices or follow novices through training. Influential early results include a 2004 report of unusually strong gamma-band brain activity in long-term Tibetan Buddhist meditators, studies showing that attention performance improved after three months of intensive retreat, and imaging studies of compassion practice. Tibetan categories of meditation, such as the distinction between concentration and analytical practice, have helped scientists define what is being measured.","The field has also been criticised. A 2018 review by fifteen researchers, titled ‘Mind the Hype’, warned of small samples, weak control conditions, inconsistent definitions and enthusiastic reporting. Daniel Goleman and Richard Davidson, two of the field’s founders, concluded in 2017 that only a small fraction of published studies met the highest methodological standards. Current work emphasises larger trials, preregistration and attention to adverse effects, while continuing to draw on contemplative traditions for hypotheses."],"facts":[{"label":"Origin","value":"Mind and Life dialogues; laboratories in the United States and Europe"},{"label":"Period","value":"1990s to the present"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Francisco Varela, Richard Davidson, Antoine Lutz, Matthieu Ricard"},{"label":"Method","value":"EEG, MRI and behavioural testing of meditators"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Lutz et al., PNAS 101 (2004); Van Dam et al., 'Mind the Hype' (2018)"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Mind and Life Institute; Center for Healthy Minds, Wisconsin"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Small samples, self-selection and weak controls in many studies"}],"related":["science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/richard-davidson-studies","science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology","science/compassion-research","science/tummo-research","science/tukdam-research","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/science-of-mind","science/herbert-benson-tummo-studies","science/high-altitude-adaptation","concepts/compassion","concepts/shamatha"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Lutz et al., Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice — PNAS 101 (2004)","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15534199/"},{"title":"Mind and Life Institute — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_and_Life_Institute"},{"title":"Van Dam et al., Mind the Hype: A Critical Evaluation and Prescriptive Agenda for Research on Mindfulness and Meditation — Perspectives on Psychological Science 13 (2018)","url":""},{"title":"Daniel Goleman and Richard J. Davidson, Altered Traits: Science Reveals How Meditation Changes Your Mind, Brain, and Body (Avery, 2017)","url":""}]},{"id":"francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology/","code":"FT·SCI·031","name":"Francisco Varela and Neurophenomenology","aliases":["Francisco Varela","Neurophenomenology","Francisco J. Varela","The Embodied Mind"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"1946–2001","summary":"Francisco Varela (1946–2001), a Chilean neuroscientist and Buddhist practitioner, co-founded the Mind and Life dialogues and proposed neurophenomenology.","body":["Francisco Varela was a biologist and neuroscientist whose work linked the scientific study of the brain with disciplined attention to experience. Born in Chile in 1946 and trained at Harvard, he first became known for the theory of autopoiesis, developed with Humberto Maturana, which describes living systems as self-producing. He took up Tibetan Buddhist practice in 1974 as a student of Chogyam Trungpa and later of Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche. From the late 1980s he worked in Paris as a research director at the national research centre.","With Evan Thompson and Eleanor Rosch he wrote The Embodied Mind (1991), which argued that cognition arises from the activity of a body in its environment and drew on Buddhist analyses of experience. In a 1996 paper in the Journal of Consciousness Studies he proposed neurophenomenology as a ‘methodological remedy’ for the hard problem of consciousness: careful first-person reports, given by subjects trained to observe their experience, should guide the analysis of brain data and be constrained by it in turn.","Varela’s laboratory tested the approach in studies relating large-scale synchrony of brain rhythms to moments of perception, and his student Antoine Lutz carried the method into research with long-term meditators. Varela helped organise the first Mind and Life dialogue in 1987 and remained its scientific guide until his death in Paris on 28 May 2001. The approach remains debated, chiefly over how reliable trained introspection can be, and it continues in the method called microphenomenology."],"facts":[{"label":"Key figures","value":"Francisco J. Varela (1946–2001)"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Born in Chile; worked in Paris at the CNRS"},{"label":"Publication","value":"The Embodied Mind (1991, with Thompson and Rosch)"},{"label":"Key paper","value":"Neurophenomenology, Journal of Consciousness Studies 3(4), 1996"},{"label":"Method","value":"Trained first-person reports combined with measures of brain dynamics"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Co-founder of the Mind and Life Institute"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Reliability of introspective reports remains contested"}],"related":["science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/richard-davidson-studies","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/science-of-mind","masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Francisco Varela — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francisco_Varela"},{"title":"Varela, Neurophenomenology: a methodological remedy for the hard problem — Avant (reprint record)","url":"https://avant.edu.pl/en/avant/neurophenomenology-a-methodological-remedy-for-the-hard-problem"},{"title":"Francisco J. Varela, Evan Thompson and Eleanor Rosch, The Embodied Mind: Cognitive Science and Human Experience (MIT Press, 1991)","url":""}]},{"id":"richard-davidson-studies","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/richard-davidson-studies/","code":"FT·SCI·032","name":"Richard Davidson's Studies of Long-Term Meditators","aliases":["Davidson meditation studies","Gamma synchrony study","Lutz et al. 2004","Long-term meditators study","Matthieu Ricard brain study"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"from 2004","summary":"Studies led by Richard Davidson’s laboratory, beginning with a 2004 paper in PNAS, found unusual gamma-band brain activity in long-term Tibetan Buddhist meditators.","body":["Richard Davidson, born in 1951, is a psychologist and neuroscientist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who studies emotion and the brain. He met the Fourteenth Dalai Lama in 1992 and was encouraged by him to apply the methods of neuroscience to qualities such as compassion. With Tibetan Buddhist practitioners who travelled to Madison for testing, his laboratory produced some of the most widely cited findings in the scientific study of meditation.","The first major paper, by Antoine Lutz, Lawrence Greischar, Nancy Rawlings, Matthieu Ricard and Davidson, appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in November 2004. It compared eight practitioners with between 10,000 and 50,000 hours of meditation to ten student volunteers given a week of training. While generating a state of unconditional compassion, the practitioners showed sustained high-amplitude gamma-band oscillations and long-distance synchrony in the electroencephalogram, and their resting activity also differed from the controls’.","Later studies from the group reported differences in attention-related brain activity and in responses to emotional sounds during compassion meditation. The authors themselves noted limitations: the groups were small and differed in age and culture, and a comparison of experts with novices cannot show that practice caused the differences. Critics have also raised the difficulty of separating gamma signals from muscle activity. Davidson founded the Center for Healthy Minds at Wisconsin in 2008 to continue the work with larger, longitudinal designs."],"facts":[{"label":"Key figures","value":"Richard J. Davidson, Antoine Lutz, Matthieu Ricard"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Lutz et al., PNAS 101(46): 16369–16373 (2004)"},{"label":"Method","value":"EEG of 8 long-term practitioners and 10 novice controls"},{"label":"Finding","value":"High-amplitude gamma oscillations and synchrony during compassion meditation"},{"label":"Practice","value":"Unconditional (non-referential) compassion, Nyingma and Kagyu traditions"},{"label":"Institution","value":"University of Wisconsin-Madison; Center for Healthy Minds (2008)"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Small, unmatched groups; cross-sectional; causation not shown"}],"related":["science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/compassion-research","science/tukdam-research","science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology","concepts/compassion","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/herbert-benson-tummo-studies"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Lutz et al., Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice — PNAS 101 (2004), PubMed record","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15534199/"},{"title":"Lutz et al. 2004, full text — PubMed Central","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC526201"},{"title":"Richard Davidson — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Davidson"}]},{"id":"compassion-research","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/compassion-research/","code":"FT·SCI·033","name":"Compassion Research","aliases":["Compassion training research","CCARE","CBCT","Compassion Cultivation Training","Cognitively-Based Compassion Training"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"from the mid-2000s","summary":"Compassion research tests secular training programmes adapted from Tibetan Buddhist mind training, notably CBCT at Emory and CCT at Stanford’s CCARE.","body":["Since the mid-2000s psychologists and neuroscientists have studied whether compassion can be deliberately trained. Much of this work uses programmes adapted from the Tibetan Buddhist tradition of lojong, or mind training, with its religious content removed. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama has encouraged the effort as part of his advocacy of secular ethics, and several of the programme designers are former Tibetan monks with Western academic training.","Cognitively-Based Compassion Training, CBCT, was developed at Emory University by Lobsang Tenzin Negi. A randomised study of sixty-one adults published in 2009 found no overall difference between the trained group and controls in stress responses, but within the trained group more practice was associated with lower inflammatory and distress responses. At Stanford, the Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education, CCARE, was founded in 2008 by the neurosurgeon James Doty with a donation of 150,000 dollars from the Dalai Lama; its eight-week Compassion Cultivation Training was principally designed by Thupten Jinpa.","Other groups have contributed. At Wisconsin, a 2013 study reported that two weeks of compassion training increased generous behaviour in a laboratory game and altered brain responses to suffering. In Germany, Tania Singer’s group distinguished empathic distress from compassion and showed that each could be trained. Reviewers note that samples are often small, outcomes frequently self-reported and long-term effects little studied. The programmes are now taught in schools, hospitals and universities in many countries."],"facts":[{"label":"Origin","value":"Secular adaptations of Tibetan lojong (mind training)"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Lobsang Tenzin Negi, Thupten Jinpa, James Doty, Tania Singer"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Emory University; CCARE, Stanford (founded 2008)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Multi-week courses tested in randomised and laboratory studies"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Pace et al., Psychoneuroendocrinology 34 (2009)"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Practice time linked to lower stress-induced IL-6; no overall group effect"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Small samples; self-report measures; few long-term follow-ups"}],"related":["concepts/compassion","concepts/lojong","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/richard-davidson-studies","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","concepts/bodhichitta","science/mind-and-life-dialogues"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mission and Vision — Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education, Stanford","url":"https://ccare.stanford.edu/about/mission-vision/"},{"title":"Pace et al., Effect of compassion meditation on neuroendocrine, innate immune and behavioral responses to psychosocial stress — University of Arizona research record","url":"https://experts.arizona.edu/en/publications/effect-of-compassion-meditation-on-neuroendocrine-innate-immune-a/"},{"title":"James Doty (physician) — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Doty_(physician)"},{"title":"Weng et al., Compassion Training Alters Altruism and Neural Responses to Suffering — Psychological Science 24 (2013)","url":""}]},{"id":"tukdam-research","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tukdam-research/","code":"FT·SCI·034","name":"Tukdam Research","aliases":["Tukdam","Thukdam","Thugs dam","Post-mortem meditation studies","Tukdam Project"],"tibetan":"ཐུགས་དམ","wylie":"thugs dam","sanskrit":"","category":"Contemplative Science","era":"research from the 2000s; first paper 2021","summary":"Tukdam research investigates reports that the bodies of some Tibetan Buddhist meditators show little decay for days after clinical death; findings are preliminary.","body":["Tukdam is an honorific Tibetan term for meditation that is also used for a state said to occur at death. According to the tradition, an accomplished practitioner may remain absorbed in the ‘clear light’ of the mind after breathing and heartbeat have stopped. During this period, which may last from days to weeks, the body is reported to stay supple, to keep a lifelike complexion and warmth near the heart, and to show little odour or decay.","The Fourteenth Dalai Lama asked scientists to investigate, and a field study was set up by Richard Davidson’s Center for Healthy Minds with Tibetan physicians in India. Its first peer-reviewed report, by Dylan Lott and colleagues, appeared in Frontiers in Psychology in January 2021. The team recorded electroencephalograms from thirteen people regarded as being in tukdam and found no detectable brain activity or evoked responses. The earliest recording was made twenty-six hours after death.","The authors stressed the limits of the result: the delay before recording, the small number of cases and the sensitivity of field equipment mean that brief activity soon after death cannot be excluded, and the study did not test the reported slowness of decomposition. Later work has proposed forensic measures of the body’s condition and has examined how monastic attendants recognise the state. No physiological explanation has been established. A documentary on the project, Tukdam: Between Worlds, was released in 2022."],"facts":[{"label":"Tibetan name (phonetic)","value":"Tukdam"},{"label":"Meaning","value":"Honorific for meditative practice; a post-death meditative state"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Center for Healthy Minds, Wisconsin, with Tibetan physicians in India"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Lott et al., Frontiers in Psychology (28 January 2021)"},{"label":"Method","value":"EEG and evoked responses recorded after clinical death"},{"label":"Finding","value":"No detectable EEG activity in 13 cases; earliest at 26 hours"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Delayed access; small sample; decomposition not yet quantified"}],"related":["science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/richard-davidson-studies","science/dalai-lama-and-science","concepts/bardo","texts/bardo-thodol","concepts/phowa","medicine/men-tsee-khang","concepts/rainbow-body"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Lott et al., No Detectable Electroencephalographic Activity After Clinical Declaration of Death Among Tibetan Buddhist Meditators in Apparent Tukdam — Frontiers in Psychology (2021)","url":"https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.599190"},{"title":"New Science Explores Process of Death — Center for Healthy Minds","url":"https://centerhealthyminds.org/news/new-science-explores-process-of-death-with-cultural-medical-and-ethical-implications"},{"title":"Tukdam — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tukdam"}]},{"id":"mind-and-life-dialogues","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/mind-and-life-dialogues/","code":"FT·SCI·035","name":"Mind and Life Dialogues","aliases":["Mind & Life","Mind and Life Institute","Mind and Life conferences","Dalai Lama science dialogues"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"from 1987","summary":"The Mind and Life Dialogues are meetings between the Fourteenth Dalai Lama and scientists, begun at Dharamsala in 1987, that helped found contemplative science.","body":["The Mind and Life Dialogues are a series of extended conversations between the Fourteenth Dalai Lama, other Buddhist scholars and working scientists. They were conceived in the early 1980s by the American entrepreneur Adam Engle and the Chilean neuroscientist Francisco Varela, who separately approached the Dalai Lama with the idea and then joined forces. The first meeting took place at the Dalai Lama’s residence in Dharamsala in October 1987 and lasted a week.","The format set at that meeting has largely continued: a small group of scientists presents current research in the mornings, with two interpreters, and the afternoons are given to discussion. Topics have included the cognitive sciences, emotions and health, sleep, dreaming and dying, physics and cosmology, destructive emotions, neuroplasticity, ethics and economics. The Mind and Life Institute was incorporated in the United States in 1991. By 2019 it had hosted thirty-three dialogues with the Dalai Lama, many published as books.","From 2000 the institute also promoted laboratory research on meditation. A public conference at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2003 drew some 1,200 people, and a summer research institute and the Francisco J. Varela research grants followed in 2004. An international symposium on contemplative studies has met since 2012. The institute is based in Charlottesville, Virginia, with a sister organisation in Europe. The dialogues also encouraged the teaching of science in Tibetan monasteries."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"First dialogue October 1987, Dharamsala; institute incorporated 1991"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Fourteenth Dalai Lama, Francisco Varela, Adam Engle"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Mind and Life Institute, Charlottesville, Virginia"},{"label":"Method","value":"Week-long presentations and discussion between scientists and Buddhist scholars"},{"label":"Number","value":"33 dialogues with the Dalai Lama by 2019"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Gentle Bridges (1992); Destructive Emotions (2003) and other volumes"},{"label":"Programmes","value":"Summer Research Institute and Varela grants, from 2004"}],"related":["science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/richard-davidson-studies","masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama","science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","science/science-for-monks","science/compassion-research","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","science/science-of-mind","science/tummo-research","places/dharamsala","concepts/dream-yoga"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Mind and Life Institute — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_and_Life_Institute"},{"title":"Mind & Life Institute","url":"https://www.mindandlife.org/"},{"title":"Jeremy W. Hayward and Francisco J. Varela (eds.), Gentle Bridges: Conversations with the Dalai Lama on the Sciences of Mind (Shambhala, 1992)","url":""}]},{"id":"dalai-lama-and-science","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/dalai-lama-and-science/","code":"FT·SCI·036","name":"The Dalai Lama and Science","aliases":["Fourteenth Dalai Lama and science","The Universe in a Single Atom","Buddhism and science dialogue","Dalai Lama science engagement"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"from the 1970s","summary":"The Fourteenth Dalai Lama has engaged scientists for half a century, holding that Buddhism must revise any claim that science conclusively shows to be false.","body":["The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, Tenzin Gyatso, born in 1935, has made dialogue with science a lasting part of his public life. He traces the interest to his boyhood in Lhasa, where he took apart watches, repaired a film projector and studied the moon through a telescope. After going into exile he sought out scientists, among them the physicists Carl Friedrich von Weizsacker and David Bohm and the philosopher Karl Popper, and from 1987 he met researchers regularly through the Mind and Life dialogues.","He set out his position in The Universe in a Single Atom, published in 2005. Its best-known statement is that if scientific analysis conclusively demonstrates a Buddhist claim to be false, Buddhists must accept the finding and abandon the claim. He applies this to the traditional cosmology of Mount Meru. He also distinguishes what science has not found from what it has shown not to exist, and on that basis does not regard rebirth as disproved. He argues that science needs an ethical framework that it cannot supply for itself.","His practical initiatives include support for laboratory studies of meditation, a much-discussed lecture to the Society for Neuroscience in Washington in November 2005, and the introduction of science teaching for Tibetan monks and nuns. At his direction Tibetan scholars compiled the multi-volume Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics, published in English from 2017. He received the Templeton Prize in 2012. Commentators differ on how far Buddhism and science share methods, a question he treats as open."],"facts":[{"label":"Key figures","value":"Tenzin Gyatso, Fourteenth Dalai Lama (born 1935)"},{"label":"Publication","value":"The Universe in a Single Atom (Morgan Road Books, 2005)"},{"label":"Principle","value":"Claims conclusively disproved by science are to be abandoned"},{"label":"Method","value":"Dialogue with scientists; support for research and science education"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Mind and Life Institute; Emory-Tibet Science Initiative"},{"label":"Period","value":"1970s to the present"},{"label":"Related work","value":"Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics (from 2017)"}],"related":["masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","science/science-for-monks","science/mount-meru","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/pramana","science/atomism-in-buddhist-philosophy","science/abhidharma-cosmology","science/science-of-mind","science/herbert-benson-tummo-studies","science/francisco-varela-and-neurophenomenology","science/richard-davidson-studies","science/compassion-research","science/tukdam-research","science/high-altitude-adaptation"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"The Universe in a Single Atom — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Universe_in_a_Single_Atom"},{"title":"Mind and Life Institute — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_and_Life_Institute"},{"title":"Dalai Lama, The Universe in a Single Atom: The Convergence of Science and Spirituality (Morgan Road Books, 2005)","url":""},{"title":"Science and Philosophy in the Indian Buddhist Classics, Vol. 1: The Physical World, ed. Thupten Jinpa (Wisdom Publications, 2017)","url":""}]},{"id":"emory-tibet-science-initiative","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/emory-tibet-science-initiative/","code":"FT·SCI·037","name":"Emory-Tibet Science Initiative","aliases":["ETSI","Emory-Tibet Partnership","Robert A. Paul Emory-Tibet Science Initiative","Monastic science curriculum"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"from 2006","summary":"The Emory-Tibet Science Initiative, begun in 2006, created a six-year science curriculum now taught in the major Tibetan monastic universities in India.","body":["The Emory-Tibet Science Initiative, ETSI, is a programme of Emory University in Atlanta that brings modern science into Tibetan monastic education. It grew out of a partnership between Emory and Tibetan institutions in India and was undertaken at the request of the Fourteenth Dalai Lama, who had long wished science to become part of the core training of monks and nuns. Planning began in 2006, and the faculty’s plan was presented to the Dalai Lama in 2007.","A pilot phase ran from 2008 to 2013 in Dharamsala with the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives, teaching ninety-one monks and nuns drawn from the Gelug, Sakya, Nyingma, Kagyu and Bon traditions. In the summer of 2014 the programme moved to three major Gelug monastic universities in southern India. Its six-year curriculum covers the philosophy of science, physics, biology and neuroscience. Enrolment rose from 345 in 2014 to 1,496 in 2019.","The work required a new scientific vocabulary in Tibetan. ETSI has produced nineteen bilingual textbooks, coined and standardised more than 6,000 terms and published a science dictionary in 2019. Selected monastics study at Emory and return as teachers, and local instructors now deliver much of the course. Supporters describe it as the most significant change to the Tibetan monastic curriculum in about six centuries. The initiative is directed by Lobsang Tenzin Negi."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"2006; pilot 2008–2013; implementation from 2014"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Emory University, Atlanta, with Tibetan monastic universities in India"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Fourteenth Dalai Lama; Lobsang Tenzin Negi"},{"label":"Method","value":"Six-year curriculum: philosophy of science, physics, biology, neuroscience"},{"label":"Enrolment","value":"345 monastics in 2014; 1,496 in 2019"},{"label":"Publication","value":"19 bilingual textbooks; science dictionary (2019)"},{"label":"Finding","value":"More than 6,000 scientific terms coined in Tibetan"}],"related":["science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/science-for-monks","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/collected-topics","science/monastic-debate","science/compassion-research","places/drepung","places/sera"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"ETSI Overview — Emory University","url":"https://tibet.emory.edu/etsi-overview.html"},{"title":"Center for Contemplative Science and Compassion-Based Ethics — Emory University","url":"https://tibet.emory.edu/"},{"title":"Mind and Life Institute — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_and_Life_Institute"}]},{"id":"science-for-monks","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/science-for-monks/","code":"FT·SCI·038","name":"Science for Monks","aliases":["Science for Monks and Nuns","Science for Monks program","Monastic science workshops","Science Leadership Institute"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"from 2001","summary":"Science for Monks is a programme founded in 2001 that brings scientists to India to teach Tibetan Buddhist monks and nuns through intensive workshops.","body":["Science for Monks was the first sustained programme of science education for Tibetan monastics in exile. It was founded in 2001 by the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives in Dharamsala and the Sager Family Foundation of Boston, in response to the Fourteenth Dalai Lama’s call for monks to learn modern science. The programme later added nuns and took the name Science for Monks and Nuns.","Its method is the intensive workshop. Scientists and science educators from American and other universities and museums travel to India for sessions of two to four weeks, teaching physics, biology, chemistry, mathematics, neuroscience and cosmology through experiment and discussion. Participants are selected scholars from monasteries of the various Tibetan schools, many of them holders of the geshe degree. Early reports counted more than thirty visiting teachers and several hundred monastic participants.","As graduates became teachers, the emphasis shifted to training leaders who run science centres in their home monasteries and nunneries. With help from the Smithsonian Institution and other museums, monastics have designed bilingual exhibitions that present scientific and Buddhist accounts of perception side by side. The programme works beside the larger Emory-Tibet Science Initiative and the Swiss-based Science Meets Dharma. Organisers describe the exchange as two-way, with visiting scientists learning from the monastic practice of debate."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"2001"},{"label":"Institution","value":"Library of Tibetan Works and Archives; Sager Family Foundation"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Fourteenth Dalai Lama; Geshe Lhakdor; Bobby Sager"},{"label":"Method","value":"Workshops of two to four weeks taught by visiting scientists"},{"label":"Origin","value":"Dharamsala and Tibetan monasteries in India"},{"label":"Partners","value":"Smithsonian Institution and science museums"}],"related":["science/emory-tibet-science-initiative","science/dalai-lama-and-science","science/mind-and-life-dialogues","science/monastic-debate","places/dharamsala","masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama","science/collected-topics"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"In India, Smithsonian works with the Science for Monks Program to Create Intercultural Dialogue — Smithsonian Global","url":"https://global.si.edu/success-stories/india-smithsonian-works-science-monks-program-create-intercultural-dialogue"},{"title":"Seeing Science Through a Spiritual Lens, with the Smithsonian's Help — Office of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, 2010","url":"https://www.dalailama.com/news/2010/seeing-science-through-a-spiritual-lens-with-the-smithsonians-help"},{"title":"ETSI Overview — Emory University","url":"https://tibet.emory.edu/etsi-overview.html"}]},{"id":"high-altitude-adaptation","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/high-altitude-adaptation/","code":"FT·SCI·039","name":"High-Altitude Adaptation","aliases":["Tibetan high-altitude adaptation","EPAS1","Denisovan gene in Tibetans","Tibetan altitude genetics"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"research from 2010","summary":"Genetic studies show that Tibetans carry variants, notably in the gene EPAS1, that aid life in thin air; one variant derives from archaic Denisovan-like humans.","body":["This entry describes modern scientific research about Tibetans; it is not part of the classical Tibetan sciences. People native to the Tibetan Plateau live at altitudes above 4,000 metres, where each breath holds about forty per cent less oxygen than at sea level. Physiologists have long observed that Tibetans cope differently from lowlanders: their blood haemoglobin concentration stays comparatively low, which avoids the thickened blood that troubles acclimatised visitors.","In 2010 three research groups, publishing in Science and in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, identified strong signs of natural selection in Tibetans at genes of the oxygen-sensing pathway, above all EPAS1, with EGLN1 also implicated. A 2014 paper in Nature by Emilia Huerta-Sanchez, Rasmus Nielsen and colleagues sequenced the EPAS1 region in forty Tibetans and forty Han Chinese and found that the Tibetan version closely matches DNA of the Denisovans, an archaic human group, indicating that it entered modern humans through interbreeding.","A Denisovan jawbone about 160,000 years old, reported in 2019 from a cave at roughly 3,200 metres in Xiahe, Gansu, shows that archaic humans occupied the plateau’s margins long before modern people. A 2021 analysis estimated that the variant entered the ancestors of Tibetans about 48,000 years ago and came under strong selection only within the last 9,000 years or so. These dates carry wide uncertainty, and how the variant alters physiology is still being worked out."],"facts":[{"label":"Subject","value":"Science about Tibetans, not a traditional Tibetan science"},{"label":"Key figures","value":"Cynthia Beall, Rasmus Nielsen, Emilia Huerta-Sanchez, Tatum Simonson"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Huerta-Sanchez et al., Nature 512: 194–197 (2014)"},{"label":"Earlier work","value":"Yi et al. and Simonson et al., Science (2010); Beall et al., PNAS (2010)"},{"label":"Method","value":"Resequencing of EPAS1 in 40 Tibetans and 40 Han Chinese"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Tibetan EPAS1 haplotype derives from Denisovan-like introgression"},{"label":"Limitations","value":"Timing and physiological mechanism remain uncertain"}],"related":["science/tibetan-plateau-third-pole","places/lhasa","places/namtso","places/mount-kailash","science/contemplative-neuroscience","science/dalai-lama-and-science"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Huerta-Sanchez et al., Altitude adaptation in Tibetans caused by introgression of Denisovan-like DNA — Nature 512 (2014)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/nature13408"},{"title":"Yi et al., Sequencing of 50 Human Exomes Reveals Adaptation to High Altitude — Science 329 (2010)","url":"https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1190371"},{"title":"Xiahe mandible — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiahe_mandible"},{"title":"Zhang et al., The history and evolution of the Denisovan-EPAS1 haplotype in Tibetans — PNAS 118 (2021), PubMed Central","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8179186"}]},{"id":"tibetan-plateau-third-pole","url":"https://forevertibet.com/science/tibetan-plateau-third-pole/","code":"FT·SCI·040","name":"Tibetan Plateau, the Third Pole","aliases":["Third Pole","Tibetan Plateau","Asian Water Tower","Qinghai-Tibet Plateau","Roof of the World"],"tibetan":"","wylie":"","sanskrit":"","category":"Science Dialogue","era":"","summary":"The Tibetan Plateau, the world’s highest and largest, holds the greatest store of ice outside the polar regions and feeds the major rivers of Asia.","body":["This entry summarises modern earth science about Tibet’s physical setting. The Tibetan Plateau covers about 2.5 million square kilometres at an average elevation above 4,500 metres, bounded by the Himalaya to the south, the Karakoram to the west and the Kunlun and Qilian ranges to the north. It was raised by the collision of the Indian and Eurasian plates, which began some fifty to fifty-five million years ago and continues today.","Scientists call the plateau and its surrounding ranges the Third Pole because they hold more ice than anywhere outside the Arctic and Antarctic, in tens of thousands of glaciers. They also call it the Asian Water Tower. The Yellow River, Yangtze, Mekong, Salween, Brahmaputra, Indus and Sutlej all rise on the plateau, several of them near Mount Kailash, and their basins support a large share of the population of Asia, by one recent estimate almost two billion people.","The region is warming faster than the global average. A 2012 study in Nature Climate Change led by Yao Tandong, covering more than 7,000 glaciers, found most to be shrinking, fastest in the Himalaya, while some in the Karakoram and Pamir were stable or growing. Thawing permafrost, expanding lakes and changing river flow are active subjects of research. Tibetan tradition, which regards many of these mountains and lakes as sacred, has its own long record of attention to the landscape."],"facts":[{"label":"Subject","value":"Modern earth science about Tibet, not a traditional Tibetan science"},{"label":"Area","value":"About 2.5 million square kilometres"},{"label":"Average elevation","value":"Above 4,500 metres"},{"label":"Origin","value":"India–Eurasia plate collision, from about 55–50 million years ago"},{"label":"Rivers","value":"Yellow, Yangtze, Mekong, Salween, Brahmaputra, Indus, Sutlej"},{"label":"Publication","value":"Yao et al., Nature Climate Change 2: 663–667 (2012)"},{"label":"Finding","value":"Most glaciers retreating, fastest in the Himalaya"}],"related":["science/high-altitude-adaptation","places/mount-kailash","places/lake-manasarovar","places/namtso","places/yamdrok-lake","places/lhasa","places/guge-kingdom"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Tibetan Plateau — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_Plateau"},{"title":"Yao et al., Different glacier status with atmospheric circulations in Tibetan Plateau and surroundings — Nature Climate Change 2 (2012)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate1580"},{"title":"Tibetan glaciers shrinking rapidly — Nature News, 2012","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2012.11010"},{"title":"Yao et al., The imbalance of the Asian water tower — Nature Reviews Earth and Environment 3 (2022)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-022-00299-4"}]}]}